Homeschooling is a popular educational approach that has been associated with positive research findings. However, there are concerns about the safety and quality of education provided in homeschool settings. Parents and educators are required to report suspected child abuse and neglect to the appropriate authorities or face prosecution.
Homeschooling has been criticized for its lack of support and resources for students, as well as the need for reports and deadlines to meet. Advocates for homeschooling argue that it should be restricted due to safety concerns.
To report concerns about homeschooling, parents must file a Letter of Intent with their local school district. They should also report any issues to the California Public Schools System (CPS), which can assess the children’s learning progress and provide guidance on lessons. The education department at the local council can also help with this process.
If someone reports their child as neglected, they can seek real-life reassurance from fellow homeschoolers. It is important to remember that reporting educational neglect is not always necessary, as it may be seen as insufficient or unintentional. If you suspect fraud, waste, abuse, mismanagement, or violations, you can report them to the OIG Hotline. Parents, like teachers, are required to submit quarterly reports and send a letter of intent annually to the school district.
In conclusion, while homeschooling has its benefits, it is essential to address concerns about safety, support, and legal issues related to homeschooling.
📹 Homeschooling (Record keeping)
Each state is going to have different requirements for how you report your homeschooling progress. Regardless of the …
How to report educational neglect in PA?
ChildLine in Pennsylvania is a 24-hour hotline for reporting suspected child abuse and neglect. It accepts calls from both public and professional sources, offering information, counseling, and referral services to ensure the safety and well-being of children. The line is answered by a trained intake specialist who interviews the caller to determine the most appropriate course of action. Questions may include the child’s name, physical description, location, type of incident, relationships, and contact information for involved parties. The caller can remain anonymous and is not required to provide personal contact information.
How do you discipline homeschoolers?
Starting small in homeschool behavior management can help establish authority and discipline. Encourage children to complete daily tasks, such as chores or daily tasks, to practice obedience and adherence to rules. This doesn’t have to be large, but daily. Focus on obedience at this point, not on good job performance. Remember the goals: good attitude, obedience, and timely manner. Doing well will come later. Remember to maintain a good attitude and follow the rules.
What does CPS need to remove a child in PA?
Courts may order a child’s removal if a judge believes it would protect them. In an emergency situation, a law enforcement officer or court officer may remove a child due to illness, injury, or imminent danger. A child’s decision to run away may also create grounds for removal. An emergency removal without a court order does not negate the need for a court order. The court must review the removal as soon as possible and a child may be returned home if the hearing is not held within a few days.
The child may be temporarily placed in a foster home or with relatives. To make the removal period more long-term, a CPS caseworker must provide evidence that removing the child is necessary and mandates government intervention. CPS must prove the validity of present and immediate threats to explain the removal’s necessity.
How to report homeschool neglect in California?
Homeschool families may report concerns about educational neglect to California’s Child Protective Services or the National Child Abuse Hotline. If you suspect educational neglect in a homeschool setting, report it. If you have reasonable cause to suspect it, report it. Most states rely on concerned friends, neighbors, or relatives to notice and report the issue. If you have concerns about the education being provided in a homeschool setting, report them to state or local education authorities or social services, depending on the state. The reporting process and requirements for homeschool parents vary from state to state. To learn more, click on your state on the map, choose from the list, or scroll down to learn more.
How do I report homeschool neglect in the UK?
The National Sexual Abuse and Neglect Commission (NSPCC) offers support for reporting child abuse and neglect. To contact the NSPCC Helpline, call 0808 800 5000 or email help@NSPCC. org. uk. If a child is in immediate danger, call the police on 999. To hide the page, use the ‘Hide page’ button or Ctrl + W on your keyboard. The NSPCC provides advice for reporting child abuse and neglect, and encourages individuals to contact them as soon as possible if they have concerns or suspicions.
How can you discipline a child who is misbehaving in class?
The objective of classroom discipline is to comprehend the nature of problematic behavior and the associated consequences, to administer appropriate consequences in a consistent manner, and to employ the appropriate disciplinary technique, whether calm or assertive, in order to maintain discipline and prevent misbehavior.
What is active neglect?
Active neglect can be defined as a caregiver’s deliberate refusal to fulfill their caretaking responsibilities. This can manifest in various ways, including abandonment, the denial of essential services, or the neglect of health-related needs.
What is a parental risk factor for neglect?
Child maltreatment is influenced by various factors, including individual characteristics, substance abuse, teenage parents, lower socioeconomic status, lack of social support, and high-stress levels. Factors such as mental health issues, trauma history, substance abuse, and teenage years contribute to the risk of child abuse. The child’s age, health, and social development also increase susceptibility to abuse and neglect. Infants and young children are more vulnerable to maltreatment due to their size, early development, and need for constant care.
Parenting methods, family structure, and approach to raising the child are also potential risks. Domestic violence is a frequent contributor to child maltreatment, and in 30 to 60 families where spousal abuse is involved, mistreatment of the child also occurs.
How do you homeschool an unmotivated child?
Homeschooling can be a challenging experience for parents, especially when it comes to motivating their children. One common issue is a child who believes that being homeschooled allows them to work whenever they want. This can lead to a lack of motivation and a struggle to complete tasks. To address this, it is essential to focus on one behavior at a time and use daily privileges and rewards to motivate your child.
Another issue is the pressure to work harder than your child is willing to. Homeschooling can be a battle zone, and it is crucial to be patient and understanding in order to help your child improve their behavior. By focusing on one behavior at a time and allowing your child to work on other behaviors, you can help them develop a better understanding of the expectations and expectations of homeschooling.
In conclusion, homeschooling can be a challenging experience for parents, but it is essential to find ways to motivate your child and ensure they are working towards a better future.
What is the biggest disadvantage of homeschooling?
The primary benefits of homeschooling include academic flexibility, personalized learning, stronger family bonds, community engagement, and efficient learning tailored to the child’s needs. The COVID-19 pandemic significantly increased homeschooling rates, which surged from a steady 3. 3 to 11. 1 in the fall of 2021 as schools closed and parents turned to homeschooling as an alternative. Common disadvantages of homeschooling include a lack of real-life socialization, limited access to resources and facilities, the demanding load on parents, and potential legal challenges.
Homeschooled children may have fewer peer-to-peer interactions and less exposure to diverse social environments compared to children in traditional schools. Studies show no significant difference in academic achievement between homeschooled and traditionally schooled children, with both groups performing equally well in areas like reading, math, and science. Homeschooling families may face legal challenges such as varying state regulations and potential scrutiny or restrictions on their ability to homeschool, creating uncertainty and difficulty.
Homeschooling parents often seek out community support groups, online resources, and sometimes hire tutors to supplement their knowledge and provide adequate educational opportunities for their children. Homeschooling can be particularly beneficial for children with special needs, providing a tailored learning environment that meets their specific requirements and supports their development. Some parents choose homeschooling over traditional schooling for various reasons, including concerns about the traditional school environment, the desire for a more personalized education, religious or moral beliefs, and the need to address specific learning needs or challenges.
Parents play a central role in homeschooling, acting as the primary educators and facilitators of their child’s learning. They are responsible for creating a curriculum, providing instruction, and ensuring their child’s educational progress. Homeschooling has been a popular choice for many parents due to its flexibility, personalized learning, stronger family bonds, community engagement, and efficient learning tailored to the child’s needs.
The COVID-19 pandemic has also impacted homeschooling rates, with the surge in homeschooling rates from 3. 3 to 11. 1 in the fall of 2021. However, there are common disadvantages to homeschooling, such as a lack of real-life socialization, limited access to resources and facilities, the demanding load on parents, and potential legal challenges.
Does emotional abuse need to be reported?
It is not uncommon for instances of emotional abuse to be reported in conjunction with other forms of maltreatment, including physical, sexual, or neglectful abuse. In accordance with the legal requirements pertaining to the reporting of such incidents, an individual in a position of trust, or “mandated reporter,” is obliged to disclose any information that gives rise to a “reasonable suspicion” of abuse.
📹 Reality Check: What Is Homeschooling Abuse?
Why We Have to Talk About Homeschooling and Child Abuse: …
This is the realest article I have ever seen, it’s not that my parents are abusive but overly protective, I have no friends and am so socially awkward, I’ve been homeschooled all my life and I can’t say its been much of a blessing, If I could take back all the years I’ve spent alone and isolated I would do it in a heartbeat, its true isolation is abuse and I’m so glad its my last year of homeschool I just want to be free 🙁
It’s funny how most homeschooling parents talk about how “great” homeschooling is and we usually don’t see the perspectives of the people who were actually homeschooled. (Unlike this lovely article) I am homeschooled and have experienced abuse. Though it has stopped‚ it has transpired into homeschooling neglect and not really sure what to do but I’ll try.. and anybody else out there experiencing anything like this I hope the best for you and hope you are able to seek help❤ Thank you‚ creator‚ for not only sharing your story but for providing helpful links ❤
Thank you for talking about this. My parents homeschooled me my entire childhood because they didn’t want me exposed to peer pressure and “worldly temptation.” Funny thing is my mom was actually a phenomenal teacher for the first 11-12ish years of my life. But she got sick when I was about 13 and couldn’t get out of bed, let alone homeschool five kids. My dad did nothing. We were expected to continue schooling ourselves (which obviously didn’t work.) Luckily my mom just barely made it through her health issues, but she became depressed afterward and still wasn’t able to homeschool us. Once again my dad did nothing. I’m 23 now and have been trying to get my GED for eight years. I know I’m capable of getting it, but I always lose my focus and drop it for months or years at a time. My mental health issues (which stem from my isolated upbringing, but my mom swears I was just “born that way”) make it extremely difficult to focus and maintain motivation. I get so angry when studying because all I can think when working my way through 3rd grade math is “You should already know this.” But I’m trying. I’m going to keep trying until I get there because I don’t want to carry this weight and shame of being “uneducated” for the rest of my life. I want better for myself.
Thanks for speaking out on this. My education was neglected through the guise of homeschooling. I’m now (at 26) working on my GED, which is really hard when I’m starting at a 4th grade math level. I am determined to get my education though, because I owe it to myself and all the other neglected “homeschoolers”. 👍🏻
I was abused emotionally (parentification as well) and physically and neglected, mom called it “unschooling.” I had access to the internet, and that was my escape. I didn’t know math beyond addition until I was 18. I was 60 pounds underweight by the time I got to a safe place, with many medical problems that had to be seen to. I want more contact with people who have been through what I have…
I’m 15 years old. I know this article is old but I don’t know where else to go to. Right now I’m not in school (public school) I’m being “homeschooled” but I’m not learning anything. a few years back my family didn’t have internet access so my mother taught me the basics of reading, writing, spelling, math, history, etc, all herself, but after awhile she stopped. I didn’t know it until I got up to this age and realized how often my mother would take us outside (almost 3 times a month) due to that I’ve gained unhealthy weight and bad eating habits, now I don’t know what else I should do as far as education. I feel stuck and so far I’ve been trying to learn by myself and get better with my reading and basic education but it’s not enough. I only have 3 more years until I’m suppose to graduate and end up in college but, how am I suppose to do that if I don’t have good education? I feel really dumb… and hopeless. if anyone sees this if there’s anything that could help me with this situation please tell me… thank you.
I’ve always felt alone in this area in my life. I never got the education I needed and thus has made me feel extremely stupid academically. My parents never taught me, I had to teach myself. Then I fell into a depression at the age of 13, had an alcohol addiction and was extremely suicidal. I still suffer with anxiety and depression because of this chapter of my life. It’s nice to know I’m not the only one.
While there wasn’t physical abuse for me, there was educational neglect. Long stretches of not doing anything. I had to take remedial math courses when I started community college. I felt ashamed about my education for a long time. I feel some relief reading others’ comments and knowing there are others who understand. I strongly support more oversight of homeschooling.
Thank you. This happened to me. Stupid mean ignorant fundies who are at the heart anti patriotic. I’m so sick of evangelicals and their need to be right about everything. My npd mom “homeschooled” us while she sulked in her locked bedroom for 15 years. I’m 30 now and out on my own but feel so alone and like it will never end. I don’t even tell people about my past as it hurts so bad
I relate to this I was pulled out of pre k and “homeschooled until 8th grade. Meanwhile we were isolated from anyone who could ask questions, including family. I failed the 8th grade placement test “for some reason” and started in 7th grade with a 3rd graders education and no social skills. Good times…. good times…
When I was about middle school age I got my first iPod touch and this was the first time I had a way to communicate with people outside of my house. My mom found out I was texting a girl and went ballistic on me. Our conversation wasn’t romantic at all we were just talking about things we were interested in like what games we played, what shows we watched, etc. Ever since then I’ve had horrible trust issues with my parents and people in general. I feel like when I was younger I was punished for socializing with people and today as a 22 year old I still feel like I can’t communicate with people how I really want to. It seems so effortless for others but I’ve never been able to get the hang of it.
THANK YOU! THANK YOU! THANK YOU! I am by no means against homeschooling. I mean, the alternative can raise another set of ethical dilemmas. And homeschooling doesn’t mean you have to isolate your child. But so often that happens. I was beaten when I got questions wrong. And now I’m an adult with some PTSD. And everyone (including my parents) wonder why I’m so messed up.
For people discovering this article now, r/homeschoolrecovery is a safe space to process. There’s even memes on there sometimes. You’re not alone, at all, and survivors are getting louder. There are tik toks about surviving cult abuse. The CRHE website referenced in the article description is still up and running – we’re here for each other. The past we share can be debilitating to our futures, I know. Please be well.
I was homeschooled from 2 to 12 grade. I was told I had to know what I wanted to do. I was taught that I would be more sinful in public school. The slap in the face came when my mother started substitute teaching and my dad would teach at a middle school. I’m 22 now and sucidial . My only friends have been dolls and the internet and tv. My dad would take my siblings and I too the park but where the sketchy adults would be there. Incest was happening in the house and my mom had the nerve to tell us she taught us not to have sex outside of marriage. I was growing and I think my mom got jealous of me and would spank me and my sister more. My dad beat up my oldest brother. The weirdest thing is now old mermories are coming back because my brain understands the words now because of perusal so much tv and internet I realized my siblings and I should have been taking away by cps. It’s too late now because I’m an adult. They will have to just live with the consequences for doing this to me for the rest of their lives. I want to leave but I guess the selfish part of me wants my materialistic things. But I’m so much more than that.without their children they’re nothing
I’m 18 in elementary grade science and 9th grade math and English. Don’t even know what history grade, though I’ve picked up most history stuff on my own. I have no hope for my future my mom just doesn’t seem to care about my education. Straight up used to go months without doing homework and she either didn’t notice or didn’t care. I want to make something of myself but it feels impossible at this rate. I just want to give up. I have 4 younger siblings and the only one making sure they’re actually doing work is me and even then I can’t do much. I wish I could’ve just gone to school like a normal kid.
Thanks for bringing awareness to this subject, means a lot. I was homeschooled until my first 9th grade year, when my parents put me in a small Christian school for 4 years that wasn’t much better, but at least gave me structure. During my homeschooling, My Dad was in the military and wasn’t around during the day and my mom cleaned houses to help make ends meet. Me, my brother and two sisters stayed home and basically “taught” ourselves. As you might expect from unsupervised children, we rarely did our school work which caused us all to get behind. There was no structure, no tests, no quizzes, no exams, barely any written work, and my parents never checked anything we did. It was a disaster. This was all because my parents held strict religious beliefs that forbade them from enrolling us in public school and due financial reasons they couldn’t enroll us in a private school either. To this day, me and my sibling resent our parents for the way they raised us and the abuse and neglect that could have so easily been avoided. Hopefully people with similar stories will see this article and not feel alone.
Is it considered abusive if a child repeatedly told no and disciplined (yelled at, lectured, demeaned etc.) when they beg to go to traditional public schools, are not registered as homeschooled by state so they don’t get tested or a high school diploma, isolated from other kids except when at church functions and even then limited, as well as being exposed to exaggerated fear of being bullied and mistreated as an attempt to keep the child from asking to attend public schools? TIA
I’ve seen in conventions for homeschool parents to buy resources for homeschooling and mostly just the parents attended, no kids. Sadly, only a handful brought their children. I thought this is weird. Then I started to pay attention to those handful of children there. Their behavior was the next level of hyperactive, like they had been just let out of their chain. Really incontrolable, no sense of respect over authority from outsider, no respect for objects. Braking things, it was a nightmare. When we tried to asked them to stop or behave, parents would go on a rant and threathen to sue the venue. I hated those type of events; luckily they only had them once a year. Now I see the other side of the coin through this article. Poor kids.
Is it considered abuse if you’ve been home-schooled for 16 years but in all that time the school part is only ever happened for about a year at Max altogether? Plus you have trouble controlling you’re emotions and the only people you’ve ever been friends with are online so it makes you extremely socially awkward and you barely leave the house… What should i do? I feel so trapped
I understand this an old article, but I’m hoping someone will read this. I need help recognizing if this is educational neglect or not. I’ve been homeschooled for about 6 years.. I’d say? I was pulled out from school in 5th grade and I did very little schoolwork over the course of those six years. if I did do schoolwork it didn’t really fit my grade level since my mother had to school my younger brother as well. Since around 2019-ish that’s when schooling became more irrelevant. We haven’t picked up a single piece of schoolwork since then. I would stress about it to my mother and ask her for guidance and all she could say was “You’re old enough to figure it out yourself. You have a phone, use google” I’m now a young adult and I feel so helpless in a way because I was never instructed or taught the way I needed to be. If I wanted to learn something, I had to do it myself because my mother would get very angry with me. She reminded me all the time that I was difficult to teach.
I am 20 and struggling trying to get my life back together, I was homeschooled since age 9 and basically ignored the entire time. I never received help more than a couple times and my mother would say “I just didn’t want help”, I was put in front of a computer on a site called time4learning and expected to figure it out while also struggling with ADHD that I was taken off my meds for, I basically got nothing done for years. The isolation, lack of friends and hopelessness I felt all the time had horrible effects on my mental health that are still present and I am trying to get mental help but I just don’t know where to get it, I’ve asked my parents for a few years if I can see a psychiatrist but it was just kind of brushed off every time. I do have an amazing sister thankfully who helped me get my GED, and I am making steps forward it is just very difficult.
I am so sorry for you guys.. You deserve a voice.. I don’t buy the “naivety” of people saying in 21 ct.. I never thought abuse could happen through home schooling.. It is creepy.. People know it.. Hope the world will listen to to your voices.. You need a stronger voice.. This is just horrendous what is going on with this home school propaganda suddenly.. I feel like exploding for all those kids.. I mean it is so true and sincere how you said it.. Poor souls.. Poor.. Poor souls.. I know what is child abuse, and by the bare thought of being out of radar of society… I mean horrible things are ment to happen.. JESUS..
I homeschool my kids and they have friends and we go to outdoor activities almost every day of the week. Anyone who’s been homeschooling for more than a year and has not yet connected with a homeschool activity group or co-op must be seen with suspicion. The first thing any homeschooling parent finds out when considering homeschooling is how to socialize their kids; if a parent has not made any attempt at finding friends for their kids (especially if the child is over 6 years old), it’s a huge red flag.
I was homeschooled. The household was decent and generally safe, despite my mom’s manic behavior and dad’s PTSD. Oh, the worst part? The huge megachurch down my street. My sister was sucked into that place, being reshaped into a acolyte of the church’s ideology. my brother and i were sucked into that place for years, we managed to escape once and for all. It even hypnotized my parents, but they wisely backed away from it very very early. That church was a nasty contributor to my early development.
Its sad how pro-Homeschooling types tend to downplay this problem simply because they technically “did it right” to actively avoid these problems cropping up. Like putting extra effort into daily socialization with other children and having just as rigid and planned out schedules as a public school.
Dropped out of school when I was 7 years old. Then, I was never allowed to study with my Mom or she’d get beat and etc. Wasn’t allowed to be alone, go outside, walk down our driveway, and more. My mother and I got out of there and I’m still trying to pick of the pieces and get my education. Everything feels so hopeless, but I can’t give up. I have so many dreams and goals but I’m afraid I’ll never make it. I’m 17 now ;-; I hate how stupid this makes me feel. I hate how so many people see me as this way. They always said it was all my fault that I didn’t have an education. God dammit I just want to live. Now, whenever I try to study I get terrible anxiety and start to panic reslly badly and idk how to change it. I’m just invisible to the world, I don’t exist. Forgotten. Most people just don’t care.
Preach it sister! You did such an amazing job of summarizing the problems with homeschool. I am also a survivor of homeschool abuse. Most outsiders aren’t aware that even convicted violent, drug, sex offenders and even convicted child molesters are allowed to homeschool in all but two states- which gives them incredible freedom to abuse their own children with impunity. We need restrictions and checks and balances to protect CHILDREN’S RIGHTS and prohibit offenders from homeschooling. Please check out my website. I have another friend with a website here where he does a show called “The Angry Homeschooler.” Most outsiders don’t even know about the culture of child abuse and how “normal” and common criminal behavior is in homeschooling communities. Have you seen the HSDLA guide to hiding child abuse? So messed up. I link to it on my article Top 5 Scary Facts about Homeschool. Thanks for doing this! Please feel free to contact me. The homeschool community is so paranoid they’re willing to throw abused kids under the bus to avoid government involvement, they don’t care about kids honestly- so it’s up to us survivors to expose this mess and fight for change.
Thanks for the article. It’s definitely true that you don’t hear this side of home schooling enough.. home school parents pump it up to be Really great And you will hear a lot of their children say the same thing and you will see them repeating the home screen process with their children…. But remember they don’t have much of opinion other than their parents. They’re brainwashed like the Hitler, youth and all my siblings Disown me when. my parents did. And a lot of these kids aren’t allowed to have a different opinion than the parents. That was certainly the case with me…. Never got much of an agitation. And I certainly don’t have a high school diploma But when I was able to start my own business the door Of my family slowly began to close. heaven forbid If the younger siblings start looking Up to me instead of the parents especially since I had different views…. For one thing, I’m honest and these homes call people are living a lie. I was physically abused for giving my opinion as a kid….. When I chose not to home school my own children. I was totally disowned from the family. So was my wife from hers. She came from a similar back Ground home school all the way through like me. But i’m not gonna repeat what happened to me. it was pretty bad
I have known many families who home schooled their children for reasons like they wanted to give them Christian values, or the children were too sensitive to attend schools with large numbers, as such I have thought of this effort as a valiant one on behalf of the parents, knowing what it takes to manage children being home all day. But until perusal this article I had never seen it as a form of control on behalf of the parents, certainly no child would benefit from abuse. Oh, my goodness, an eye opener for sure. I am wondering though, what if the child kept saying: no I want to be in school, can the parent really keep them back? Let’s face it, with the size of classrooms today and the brainwashing curriculum, negative peer influence, drugs, etd, I can see why a parent would want to protect their child in the formative years.