The study investigates the relationship between parenting and corporal punishment using data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Children of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, 1979 (CNLSY). The research found that 59% of American parents believe it is a right to spank their child if they think it is necessary, while only 14% believe it is okay to discipline a child with an object such as a belt. However, research shows that physical punishment is associated with increases in delinquency, antisocial behavior, and aggression in children, and decreases in the other dimensions.
Despite significant empirical evidence of its potential harm and ineffectiveness, most American adults approve of corporal punishment (CP) and use it to correct their children’s behavior. Over 90% of American parents report having used CP at least once, and 40 to 70% report using it to correct their children’s behavior. Physical punishment is increasingly viewed as a form of violence that harms children.
The majority of American parents discipline their children physically, with over 90 reporting having used corporal punishment at least once. Although the prevalence of parents using physical discipline with their children has declined over the last 50 years, approximately two-thirds of U.S. children are punished. Public humiliation is another popular method of discipline, but it is not an effective form of discipline and does not make parents soft. Shaming and humiliation cause fear in children, which does not go away when they grow up and becomes a barrier for a healthy emotional life.
Both corporal punishment (beatings) and public humiliation (shaming) are considered child abuse, and parents are using social media to publicly shame their children into submission.
📹 Parents publicly punish kids by making them wear signs | WWYD?
NEW TO YOUTUBE: When we first broadcast this scenario on September 14, 2012, some parents were using a controversial form …
Is humiliation a form of control?
Humiliation is a form of oppression or abuse used in various contexts, such as police, military, or prisons, to assert power over individuals. It is often used as a means of making an example and presenting a deterrent to others. Some practices, such as tarring and feathering, have become tools of unofficial mob justice. In folk customs, such as skimmington rides and rough music, dramatic public demonstrations of moral disapproval were enacted to humiliate transgressors and drive them out of the community.
Some U. S. states have experimented with humiliating or shaming lawbreakers by publishing their names and indicating their offense. In 2010, public outcry was raised about reports showing police in Dongguan and Guangdong leading a parade of arrested prostitutes for the purpose of humiliating them. The national Ministry of Public Security reprimanded the local police and affirmed that such punishments are not allowed. Humiliation is a powerful factor in human affairs that has been overlooked by students of individual and collective behavior.
What is the most horrible punishment?
Capital punishment is a controversial issue, with arguments that it is more expensive and the government has been wrong in past cases. However, these arguments may not be enough to qualify for the government’s tests, which could be considered arbitrary. Capital punishments have been deliberately cruel, painful, and degrading throughout history. Examples include breaking wheel, hanging, drawing and quartering, mazzatello, boiling to death, death by burning, drowning, feeding alive to predatory animals, starvation, immurement, flaying, disembowelment, crucifixion, impalement, crushing, execution by elephant, keelhauling, stoning, dismemberment, sawing, slow slicing, blood eagle, bamboo torture, and necklacing.
In 2008, Michael Portillo on the show Horizon argued that to ensure an execution is not cruel and unusual, criteria must be met: quick and painless death to prevent suffering for the person being executed; medical education provided to the executioner to prevent error-related suffering; death not to be gory to prevent suffering for those carrying out the execution; and no cooperation from the person being executed to prevent inaction, distress, and suffering caused by the prisoner participating in their own execution.
What are four common forms of punishment in the US?
The criminal justice system considers four common types of punishment: incarceration, rehabilitation, diversion, and retribution. Incarceration, also known as incapacitation or imprisonment, is when a person is sentenced to prison for a specified amount of time, ranging from a few weeks to life. The sentencing length depends on the judge or jury’s decision and is usually accompanied by minimum, maximum, presumptive, or indeterminate sentences.
What are the most common punishments parents give their children?
The five most common forms of punishment include yelling, withdrawing or withholding privileges, and using “logical consequences”. These methods can be used to discipline children, such as scolding, name-calling, or demanding. During a recent trip to California, it was observed that many vacation spots were filled with families and young children, often scolding their children. This highlights the importance of understanding and addressing different parenting styles, as it can lead to a more sensitive and effective approach to parenting. The author acknowledges that their awareness of the “other” way of parenting has become highly sensitive, resulting in a selective hearing for punishment and scoldings.
What does humiliation do to a child?
Shaming children is a harmful practice that can lead to feelings of inadequacy and self-doubt. It is not just about a child’s achievements or appearance, but also about their clothing choices and relationships. Shaming can make children feel like they cannot change, leading to feelings of inadequacy and self-doubt. It can also negatively impact their self-esteem, as the opinions of those closest to them can make them feel bad about themselves.
To prevent shaming, it is essential to think before criticizing a child and ask yourself if it is something they can change and if it is important for them to change it. By doing so, we can help prevent a harmful cycle of shame and promote a more positive and supportive environment for children.
What is the cruelest form of punishment?
Drawing and quartering is a notorious form of cruel and unusual punishment, first used in England in the 13th century. The accused is drawn, tied to a horse, and dragged to the gallows, usually hanging, disemboweled, or beheaded. The condemned is then quartered, splitting their body in quarters. This punishment was reserved for those guilty of treason and was abolished in 1867.
Strappado is an uncomfortable form of torture that doesn’t necessarily end in death. The guilty party is strung up by the wrists behind the head, causing an agonizing dislocation of the shoulders. Though thought to have originated during the Inquisition, it has been used into the 21st century.
White torture is a type of sensory deprivation where a prisoner’s cell, clothes, and food are entirely white. Guards wear all white, lights are kept on 24 hours a day, and no words are spoken. Amir Fakhravar, arrested in Iran in 2004, was subjected to white torture for 8 months. Although the physical pain of sensory deprivation is minimal, the psychological damage is beyond compare. Fakhravar was unable to remember even the faces of his parents upon release.
What is the psychology behind humiliation?
Humiliation can have a significant impact on an individual’s self-esteem and overall personality. Two cognitive evaluations are assumed after experiencing humiliation: a cognitive bias, where the victim internalizes the feeling of humiliation when the self is devalued by the oppressor, and the possibility of the devaluation being assessed as unjust. This can lead to feelings of shame and embarrassment, which threaten the self. Humiliation can significantly affect self-esteem, as it can lead to undervaluation and a decline in self-confidence.
The second evaluation is the possibility of the devaluation being assessed as unjust, with anger becoming the dominant emotion if the devaluation is assessed as unfair but not internalized. Shame is the dominant emotion if the devaluation is internalized and accepted. Public exposure and the status of the oppressor are also factors that contribute to the experience of humiliation. The oppressor’s status, whether as an authority or with a personal connection, determines whether the victim can impose humiliation on others.
Is humiliation a good form of punishment?
Public shaming can have severe psychological effects, including depression, suicidal thoughts, and other mental problems. The humiliated individuals may develop symptoms such as apathy, paranoia, anxiety, PTSD, or others. The rage and fury may arise in the persecuted individual, seeking revenge or as a means of release.
Crucifixion was used by the Romans to add public humiliation to a death penalty, with crucifified bodies left to decay on the cross for weeks. The punishment of public humiliation has taken many forms, ranging from forcing an offender to relate their crime, wearing conspicuous clothing or jewelry, or being sentenced to remain exposed in a specific exposed place, in a restraining device such as a yoke or public stocks.
In the Low Countries, the schandstoel (“Chair of shame”), the kaak or schandpaal (“pole of shame”), the draaikooi (customary for adulteresses), and the schopstoel (a scaffolding from which one is kicked off to land in mud and dirt) were customary for adulteresses.
In colonial America, common forms of public humiliation were the stocks and pillory, imported from Europe. In pre-World War II Japan, adulterers were publicly exposed purely to shame them. In Liberia, boy soldiers stripped civilian women to humiliate them, while in Siam, an adulteress was paraded with a hibiscus behind the ear, thieves were tattooed on their faces, and other criminals were paraded with a device made of woven cane on the forehead or lengths of bamboo hung around the neck. Send under the yoke was used in ancient Italy.
Sex offender registries in the United States are considered a form of public humiliation as judicial punishment. A convicted sex offender’s placement on the sex offender registry is public via a state-run website in all 50 states. In 2018, a judge declared Colorado’s sex offender scheme as unconstitutional, citing cruel and unusual punishment.
What is the most popular discipline technique in the US?
The most prevalent disciplinary approach in the United States is the revocation of privileges, which entails the withdrawal of specific privileges or rewards as a consequence of misconduct. This technique is commonly employed in educational and domestic settings to encourage positive behavior.
How to discipline a child in the USA?
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends 10 healthy discipline strategies for parents to help their children learn acceptable behavior. These strategies include showing and telling, teaching right from wrong, setting limits, providing consequences, hearing out, giving attention, catching good behavior, knowing when not to respond, and being prepared for trouble. These strategies help children manage their behavior, prevent harm, and promote healthy development.
Parents should be patient and aware of when to respond and be prepared for trouble. By following these strategies, parents can help their children develop healthy behaviors and maintain a positive learning environment.
How do American parents punish their child?
Corporal punishment is a common practice in the US, with over a third of parents reporting using it on children under a year old. Researchers estimate that 85 percent of American youth have been physically punished by parents during childhood or adolescence. The most common form of corporal punishment is spanking on the buttocks with an open hand, but more than one in four parents have also reported using objects like hairbrushes or wooden spoons to hit their children.
Race, gender, and social class are significant factors in U. S. domestic corporal punishment patterns. Boys are more likely to be spanked at home, and corporal punishment of boys tends to be more severe and aggressive than that of girls. Research has shown mixed results on whether physical punishment predicts adverse outcomes in this group. Affluent families at the upper end of the socioeconomic scale tend to spank the least often, middle-class parents administer corporal punishment in greater numbers, and lower-class parents do so with still greater frequency.
A 2014 real-time investigation of mothers in Texas found that nearly half used some form of corporal punishment during the duration of the study. Subjects tended to use spanking when angry and for trivial misdeeds, such as minor social transgressions by children. The study’s lead author, George Holden, suggests that studies using self-reports may dramatically underestimate the actual incidence of spanking by parents.
📹 What Would You Do: Mother Uses Harsh Punishments on Son | What Would You Do? | WWYD
A mother punishes her child for the smallest of offenses and then resorting to putting hot sauce on his tongue. What would you do …
Any parent that mentally, emotionally, or physically abuses their child, did not have any business screwing around to make said child and should not be called a parent. As someone that has trauma stemming from bullshit like this and ass-whoopings, I can tell you right now it did not fix my behavioral issues and it gave me mental health issues. Take some advice from that one man…”Punish the behavior not the child.”
This is honestly disgusting though, that could really leave a very big negative impact on a child. Your life also, is between you and your family. Not for people to take pictures of your child. Public humiliation was literally used in the past for a way of torture. This is absolutely emotional ABUSE.
Whenever I misbehaved I got shut in my room and wasnt allowed outside until I’d calmed down. I’d overhear my parents dismissing it all as me looking for attention and they’d talk about how bad of a child I was to everyone. Family, strangers, everyone. I’m an adult and they still do it now. I didn’t realise it until I turned 23 that it wasn’t normal for parents to treat their kids that way and that compared to other kids, I was a saint. It turned out to be the root cause of my trust issues, commitment issues, lack of social skills, lack of emotional awareness and people pleasing all of which stayed with me until my mid 20s where I started noticing it and tackling it through therapy. Thats what emotional abuse does to your kids. It follows them through to their adulthood. As awesome of an idea it may seem to dissuade poor behaviour, it’s not a good idea for being a parent. Please don’t do this.
OK I can’t stand the last lady who agreed with the mother. She was being so rude to the other lady and she was being so rude to the boy telling him to keep twirling. And then she said you don’t come from a black background race has absolutely nothing to do with it she was being so rude I completely agree with the lady who said it was wrong
Humiliating your child only makes the behavior continue. Period. It increases anger between parent and child, and causes them to desire revenge by indulging in MORE risky behaviors. When the relationship is more hostile the respect on both ends of the parent child relationship lessen. Public humiliation is traumatic and can lower a persons self esteem, which can cause social issues. This is absolutely NOT the route to take with discipline. No matter what race or gender you are. This is just dehumanizing.
An actual good honest talk between a parent their child can do so much more than beating their child causing pain, confusion, aggression toward others etc or being humiliated causing anxiety, shame, a miss opportunity to be closer to your child with a real understanding why doing something like smoking, drinking etc is so wrong. How it can effect you and others especially as who people of color. I learned this at young age. I’m glad I did. I’m glad my parents are straight up the point and explained what that kind of stuff can do a person let alone the people around them. As well as being in a very opens minded and outspoken generation. Just a talk. A talk can do so much. A talk is enough. As long the talk is reasonable, honest, and real and not guilt tripping your child as well. Just A TALK can do much more than you think it can.
As a child who was both physically and emotionally abused, I agree with the last woman from the Bronx. I understand both perspectives but what I feel, have felt, and have found is that being emotionally hurt by the one person you’re supposed to trust scars you more. Glad to see articles like this. Awareness brings mindfulness. The more we talk about it, the better solution we can find.
Major stuff like stealing and smoking as a minor needs to be seriously talked about in a loving serious way, and show how bad it really is. Turning it into a gimmick by putting him on the sidewalk with a sign of the kids wrong doing is making it a joke and that’s not gonna help. It’s not stopping the kid from thinking that he can get away with it secretly next time.
This whole “you’re not (insert race/creed/gender/sexual orietation) so it’s not your place to speak up” thing is getting ridiculous. I’m gay and I’m happy when a straight person stands up for me. If you’re a witness to an abusive or discriminatory situation, you should intervene on behalf of the victim, period – identity politics be damned.
This article made me sooo angry it’s unbelievable how people can be so mean NO KID deserves that kind of punishment it’s so humiliating and will make the child HATE their parent. As an arab kid I have been beaten up soo much as a kid and violence and humiliation only made me sneakier so instead of admitting the mistakes I did and confronted my parents about them honestly I would just hide as much as I could afraid from punishment and that is so wrong so humiliating your kids is never the solution communicating with them and making them understand what they did and how badly it could affect them is much more affective
okay so i saw a comment that said “if the parents do that or think it’s okay, the kids are gonna hate them.” and i agree. “punish the behavior not the child.” exactly. the best punishment is one that ends up with both sides still loving and forgiving each other. one of the replies was “but the parents will hate the child for stealing.” and thats outrageous. a parent should not HATE their child because they made a bad mistake. teenagers can be moody and think they “hate” their parents and those feelings might fester and grow to be something that they harbor, so it’s better for a parent to be understanding but still make sure kids are growing up doing the right thing.
The problem with public humiliation is that it might not always be “a second chance,” especially if you allow people to take pictures. Since this is public, people can always talk about this and spread around, especially on the internet, hurting them in the short term. And in the long term, many people on the internet don’t really understand that people can change from 10 years ago, so it can also hurt them in the long run.
Srry no i wouldn’t do that to my child idk how black history gotta do what he or she did but sorry nope it other way to punish your child like take wat they like like article game and tv and no outside but that old school is it legal yes it is i agree with dat guy it is abusing your child but we don’t acknowledge that bcuz we always wanna be petty
My freinds mom actually made my freind to do something like this….. I fondly remember me and my friend playing but my freind accedentally spilled some juice which his mom was drinking beside us while we were running around… Then his mother took him out and punished him exactly like this and i just remembered perusal him cry while i jus had to go back home… he always told me that it happened repeatedly and was really scared to be with his mom.. Today he suffers from anxiety and depression and im not too sure wether it was because of theese punishments or jus other life experiences …. From looking at his experiences its really sad to see so many people agreeing with that punishment…..why is the world like this
In grade 2 my teacher announced that anyone who forgot to put full stops in their sentences would be getting licks, aka a beating. I sat there and meticulous wrote my sentences putting my full tops and then reviewed it when I was done. I still got licks because my teacher confused me with my twin sister. 25 years later I still never forget to add my full stops. I’m grateful for the lesson and I don’t even remember the beating but frankly I’m still angry about the injustice of it all.
So I’m getting a PhD in education, right? So I’ve needed to look at research for households, schooling, teaching, and learning. Research shows that any sort of abuse or humiliation results in fear of the parent, meaning inside the home, they are verbally respectful, but will get much better at HIDING the punished behaviors. Outside the home, it promotes worse behavior. Don’t do this. It’s disgusting.
The fact that the lady with the darker skin shade used her RACE against the white woman went a bit too far and she shouldn’t be using her race in this type of situation. Also, before you hate on me, i’m a black person myself. I respect the Black community proudly, but race shouldn’t be used this way. Edit: Sorry, forgot to mention the sexism part. I agree and disagree about this. One, boys and girls should be evenly treated. Although, history has shown that men are a lot stronger than women, and that women go through a lot in their life. Maybe that’s why people are nicer to the girl? 🤷♀️
26 year Correctional Officer here. 24 years of that working at a state run Substance abuse treatment facility or “SAFP” in Texas. I’m going to give you the information and let you make what you will from it. When we first started the program, one of the “Redirections,” we didn’t call it “punishment,” was for the Offenders to wear a sign around their neck wherever they went, telling of their infraction, if it was bad enough. We had a tool called “Tight House,” where an entire living area or “Pod,” who functioned as a “family” would sit, while not at work and face the wall, in a type of time out. Slowly, over time, all of these tools were taken away from the treatment staff until today, this wonderful program, that had a success right in the 90th percentile, now has a relapse rate the same as regular prison………………. You be the Judge.
I am very much in the grey with this only because I know how hard it is to find an appropriate punishment that ACTUALLY WORKS while not scarring a child. And to be honest, sometimes the scars are helpful to that child. I was almost left in a store as a kid and the sheer terror that ran through me made certain I always listened when it was time to leave after.
i don’t feel like the black woman at the end was wrong when it came to bringing race into the conversation. black men are targeted more than white. it would be more consequential for a black man to break the law than a white man, and therefore, her point is that they need to get any bad behavior out of them as soon as possible so they don’t end up hurt. i do feel like the punishment was wrong, though.
It’s just wrong to do that to a child who is still learning. Punishment this severe will only cause them to resent their parents, it’s emotionally damaging. This can lead to low self esteem, trust issues, anxiety, depression, and more mental issues. A parent should comfort their child, help them to learn and grow as a person from their mistakes. They shouldn’t humiliate them. Instead of punishment, just help them to learn, punishment makes people angry and builds up grudges and resentment in my opinion.
When my Sister was 12, she was caught smoking. My Father told her she had to smoke two packs of cigarettes, without stopping/no breaks, as her punishment. By the third cigarette my Sister looked greenish. By the fourth, she threw up. She NEVER smoked a cigarette again. Ever. Abuse? No. Effective? Absolutely.
This is definitely not the way to go. That man is so right punish the behaviour and not the child…it would be so humiliating especially as a teenager when you just want to fit in…imagine if someone saw you.. you would get bullied for it. There are so many other ways of changing a child’s behaviour
Back when i was 5 or 6 i tried a piece of food at the school salad bar and did not like it, One of the teachers noticed that i was not eating the food i got, After stating i did not like the food she had me sit in a chair and had every person in the cafeteria call me a baby before heading back to class. Two things happened, I became a much more picky eater, And i developed anxiety, Please stop humiliating children. Even if it does work it works at a cost.
If I was the child….. this is like nooooo right way to discipline a child! I would’ve legit hated my mom more and more, and would not respect or look up to her at alll, which doesn’t help me to stop doing bad things at allll….. what ifff! What if instead of spanking! Instead of humiliating your child! What if you love your child, care for your child, talk with your child, have conversations about what’s the right thing to do in life…. if y’all do this since they’re young, it wouldn’t reach to the limit where you have to humiliate him…. only if you loved, cared, and talked with your child 💙
Look, even if you don’t approve of the discipline method, kids need to learn consequences. I guarantee you if the behavior goes unchecked, that child will end up in prison or in the streets. There comes a point where just talking to them is not enough and you have to physically show them that they are not allowed to steal or do illegal things because the consequences as an adult will be 10 times harsher.
I get it, if a child is humiliated like that then they wont do it again, but seriously you can ruin their chances of doing something like that, but you will also ruin their mental health, this will give you nothing aside from and anxietic child, and if that kid already had anxiety this could lead to depression
All the parents out there. Hear me today. These punishments would led your kid to be sneakier and afraid rather than stopping the behavior. Please study psychology and also to make the kid understand phycology if you can. You want your kids to respect you not fear you. That’s all wish you all a good life
It depends on your child. You have to know what will and won’t hurt your child. I was arrested for illegal drug use when I was 16 4 times. The first 2 times I was grounded and lost my car. The 3rd time my dad whooped my butt. The 4th time I had to wear a sandwich board when I was arrested for doing drugs. It worked for me. I haven’t touched any kind of illegal drugs since then. No it didnt scar me whatsoever. What scarred me more is a whooping. I despise my father for doing this. I dont talk to him anymore.
I dont get how people accept this punishment. Id rather get beat than be bullied, humiliated, and being known as the freak for doing a bad thing. they wont learn anything, unless you want them to learn to have anxiety and feel depressed then idk what. if its constant then do it atleast once. but id rather not be humiliated and instead feel the burn. -my opinon
The guy taking a photo really makes me angry inside. Its humiliating enough and to ASK FOR A PHOTO. He shouldn’t have a photo of a child he doesn’t know, period. And taking a photo of a child getting a punishment means the kid knows more adults would be laughing at that. Disgusting. Humiliation doesn’t stop bad behaviour. It causes anger to fill up. It causes the child to not want to trust their parents and to run away more. They will feel unheard. Teach your child in an appropriate way and be a good example to them. Black or white. Race doesn’t matter. “Whooping” is wrong. Humiliation is wrong. Any punishment that is set out to hurt them emotionally, physically or mentally is wrong. If your child is rebelling against you as a parent, take the time to get to the bottom and figure them out. Example- Maybe they were smoking because they wanted to fit in with a crowd of people at school and were caught. Teach them that they don’t need to reduce themselves to bad or gross behaviour to be liked by other people. Teach self respect. Get them help to stop a possible addiction. Be kind and gentle with them…. Being kicked out of school is their punishment….. show them that they still have learning to maintain now they are missing out on school and ittl mean they have to work harder to catch up. Set them goals to achieve…. set them up to be a better person of themselves. You do not need to resort to these kind of discipline methods. If you feel the need to hit or humiliate your child that means YOU have work to do on yourself.
>you are on a safari >you get bitten by a snake >it was venomous, and you start feeling the effects >you fall to the ground, unable to do anything >there’s nobody around, so you can’t call for help >you decide to take the punishment that God gave you, and you close your eyes and slowly die >you wake up >”Im Johnny Quinones with What Would You Do, and it seems you just gave up and died.”
Parents are no longer parents. Everyone saying that they don’t agree to it and it wont work, and the kids have feelings- Just take a look at society and the entitled selfish kids full of self righteousness and ask yourself exactly how thats happened. Its happened because of the very philosophy the people who disagree with this have. They’re idiots who cant see the consequences of their actions. Back in tribal days this public accountability was an important part of maturity.
I’m not a parent myself but a friend of mine does something with his kids I really love. When his children do something wrong he has them do community service or perform chores for someone else. Once he was even able to set up something with the police where they could clean up public sidewalks. Because when you think about it, the idea of punishment should solely be to punish but rather allow kids to make amends for their mistakes
I think it’s important to remember these kids are HUMANS FIRST! That means, they’ll make mistakes, they’ll do bad things, they’ll do things they regret, etc. Does that mean they should be publicly shamed for it? Or is that abuse? Let’s put it into perspective. If you committed a bad act regardless of whether or not you felt guilty, it would be illegal to blackmail you. Why? Someone is using you to force shame. Another example, how would you, as a human, like it if every bad, negative, act you committed as a human being were broadcasted to the world to see? Would you stop your behavior and become as robotic as possible, or would you get frustrated, cry, and beg to not be humiliated again because you made a human mistake? Imagine if you did something bad ACCIDENTALLY? Too bad, it’ll be broadcasted for the world! That’s why it’s wrong. You are taking away a person’s right to be human. We all fuck up. If you are going to judge someone for their poor actions, you better take a look at yourself first. It’s emotional abuse and in a way, blackmail. “If you don’t do as I ask, I will humiliate you.” It will have a lasting effect in a negative way. Either the child will rebel more (so the discipline isn’t working, so why are you still doing it?) because they feel you won’t listen and talk to them, they feel disrespected, and they’ll feel like they won’t matter to you or the child will comply to you, but come to hate you. By doing this sort of thing to a child you are doing the following: 1: Exerting your power over them (showing the kid that we shouldn’t be equal and that they are not worthy of the same rights as human beings) 2: Invalidating their emotions (instead of discussion as people should do, you are simply showing who’s boss rather than teaching why an action is wrong and understanding why they do what they do) 3: Blackmailing (telling the kid to behave or you’ll humiliate them, and yes, this is bullying and from a parent, it’s abuse because you should be the person a child can trust to come to with problems, not the person a child fears) 4: Indirectly telling the child you don’t love them and you have conditional love (a parent may think they are using discipline, but what they are really doing is saying, “you’re not worth my time to listen to, you’re a problem to me, you’re causing me a headache, I’m focusing on your flaws, you’re a terrible person, and you deserve this.
What a stupid form of punishment…. This would give the kids depression, anxiety suicidal thoughts/feelings…. How would parents like it they this happened to them being humiliated in front of everyone? alot of parents need to understand that this can have a negativity effect on their kids in the long term or before they turn to adults or teens.
I’m still a 16-year-old myself, but people are being overly sensitive. If your child goes out there, bullying others, stealing and thinking it’s cool to brag about it to your friends, then not why to strangers? That’s how life works tbh, do dumb shit and you’ll get punished for it. I’m telling you this now, if you don’t teach your child from an early age that their actions have consequences, the law will do it for them. Stop telling other people how to raise their kid, maybe they’ll learn not to be an asshole towards others in the future. You get what you give. If you think it’s funny to humiliate others, prepare to be humiliated yourself.
Just SEEING this and seeing the last woman laughing and saying “kEeP tWiRLiNg” makes me INFURIATED. It would make me wanna act out and lash out on my mom even MORE. Just from perusal this article. Now if that’s not mental abuse,then I don’t know what is…It makes kids more angry and not even wanna talk to their parents.Not to mention what if the kid gets BULLIED??
I myself study mass murders so I know pretty well what can be damaging to a persons psyche and honestly that should be classified as mental abuse no matter what colour what anything children aren’t going to learn it’s doing nothing but angering or scaring the child emotionally getting rid of a bond I do not recommend doing this.
I personally agree with this method. It’s not emotional abuse, public humiliation is a good lesson for someone who needs to learn to be ashamed. Not for all “offenses”, no…because some are controversial to whether or not they even are offenses. But for things you need to not do but won’t get you arrested, like lying, this is a good last resort. I agree with the “learn the hard way” method as well. If you give it all you’ve got to try and teach them but they won’t listen, there’s nothing else to say. A weekend in jail is a good one for young thieves who can’t be talked out of their habit/mindset. Words aren’t the answer to everything, I’ve learned that personally the hard way when giving all I had in words and kindness to someone who didn’t deserve it, and didn’t care. So embarrass them while they still have the conscious for it, because once they don’t, they’re hopeless and it’s too late to fix them. Show them what they’re in store for if they don’t shape up. The only thing I don’t agree with is spanking/whipping. You should NEVER lay your hands, or anything else you might use as a WEAPON (belts for example), on a person. Especially not a child.
All the customers are sweet and great in their own way for the boy. But my deepest respect is for the 17 year old girl. She is a hero!! Despite the fact her friends told her to stay out of it, she did what she had to do for the boy… I didn’t have the courage yet at her age to stand up to an adult. Love her 😍 Amazing young woman ❤
I’ve never had that punishment, but the mother’s whole vibe and how angry and strict she is is exactly like my mother. It really is hard being such a young kid and dealing with that. You never understand why and how you’re always doing something wrong no matter what and it’s scary. Respect to these people who stood up for him.
I’ve NEVER heard of “Hot Saucing” but I am absolutely DISGUSTED with the practice of this. You do realise that exposing a child’s SENSITIVE taste buds can effect their nerve endings and quite possibly be problematic for the child’s health in the future. It’s a form of torture and ANY parent who practices this should face prison time and have their kids placed somewhere else.
I know this was posted a while ago, but can we take a moment of appreciation for the young girl who stood up for what she thought was right, despite her friend telling her to stay out of it. For a 17-year old to stand up to an adult takes amazing courage, especially with the added pressure to back out from her friend. I hope she is doing well.
Friend: Stay out of it,Stay out of it. The girl: Still helps anyways John Quinones: hey you’re on WWYD! Friend while the girl is being interviewed: Oh yeah, let me fix my hair really quick.I wouldn’t want to look bad on camera right? Edit 1: Omg, I completely forgot about this comment. Why does this have so many likes lol.
People don’t realize how harmful it is to a child when they are constantly controlled, criticized, and yelled at. And most kids are constantly in systems where they are dominated by adults (home, school, sports). I wish every kid had a relationship where they can just be themself and trust that they will be treated with love and respect.
Grew up with a kid with a mom like this about 15 years ago. I remember playing article games at his place and she popped off over him not perusal his little brother after he fell on his butt and stated crying. His mom come in and insisted my friend let him get hurt on purpose along with a few whacks upside the head. She kicked him out of the house barefoot without a jacket in the snow. We had to walk 2 miles back to my house on that cold snowy day. Not too long after I moved away but I ran into him a few years back where he worked and she completely ruined his life. I always thought about him and felt bad we couldn’t do more for him at the time. I hope one day he’ll be at peace mentally.