In 2023, approximately 25% of children aged 1 to 3 years and 9 of children aged 4 to 5 years were on a waitlist. Over one million children aged 0 to 5 years were in child care, with nearly 1.2 million Canadian children younger than 6 years old in early care. The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted early learning and child care, with just over half of Canadian children younger than 6 in regulated or home-based settings.
The Government of Canada’s campaign page promotes a federal childcare initiative of $10 per day for early learning and child care. The cost of child care for families is only $10 per day for full-time child care, $7 a day for part-time child care, or free for families earning under $40,000. Educators earn a fair wage averaging $25 per hour, plus.
In 2022, 45,366 businesses across Canada provided child care services to children aged 0 to 12 years. 31 were child care centers, 33 were home-based settings operating with a license, and 31 were child care centres. The best option for Saturday and Sunday childcare depends on individual circumstances and the child’s needs.
From January 1, 2024, the maximum hourly rate for day care and preschool is € 9.65, while the maximum hourly rate for after-school care is € 8.30. A parent or non-parent carer’s percentage of care for a child is calculated based on the care they are likely to provide or have provided.
To calculate monthly net costs, use a calculator to check if you are eligible for childcare leave and how much leave you are entitled to. If you need weekend childcare, browse local weekend child care on Care.com and estimate what Child Care Subsidy payments will offset your daily fee based on your family circumstances.
📹 The Fourth Commandment: Remember The Sabbath | Belief It Or Not
This is the moment! https://www.vote.org/ Special thanks to the Better Internet Initiative This one is less of a commandment and …
What country spends the most on childcare?
The US spends 0. 4 of its GDP on early education and childcare, compared to 0. 8 for the average OECD country. Iceland spends more than the US, at about 1. 7 of the country’s GDP. A 2021 New York Times analysis found that the US spends roughly $500 a year per child on early childhood care, compared to over $14, 000 for the average OECD country. Cindy Lehnhoff, director of the National Child Care Association, said it would take federal government investment to balance childcare spending with other budget priorities. Additional childcare funding could have been provided through the Build Back Better legislation in 2021.
What is the hourly rate for a nanny in Netherlands?
The remuneration for nanny services varies depending on the number of children in the household. For one child, the rate ranges from €11. 50 to €13. 50 per day. For two or three children, the rate is between €12. 50 and €15. 00. For four children, the rate is between €15. 00 and €17. 50. Evening care is available at a rate of €10. Parents may register as a nanny, search for available positions, and obtain references. Amsternannies facilitates connections between families in Amsterdam and individuals offering babysitting services, with the objective of providing flexible solutions to childcare needs.
What percentage of 2 year olds go to daycare?
In 1994, 10. 3 million children under the age of 5 were in child care while their mothers worked, including 1. 7 million infants under 1 year of age. The majority of 5-year-olds are in kindergarten (88. 5 percent in 1995). Younger children are enrolling in center-based child care, preschool, and pre-kindergarten programs at increasing rates, with 45 percent of 3- and 4-year-olds and 22 percent of children younger than 3 in these types of programs by 1997.
This dramatic change has led to growing acceptance of child care as supplementing rather than competing with parental care and persistent worries about the effects of child care on children’s development. Decisions about the care and supervision of young children are among the oldest problems faced by human society. Over the history of family life and across cultures, mothers have had multiple duties that have necessitated sharing the handson care of their infants and toddlers with others, primarily other women relatives and older children.
In conclusion, the increasing acceptance of child care as a supplement to parental care and concerns about its effects on children’s development are significant challenges faced by parents today.
How much is daycare in NL?
On January 1, 2023, child care costs in Newfoundland and Labrador were reduced to $10 a day, a move implemented three years ahead of the deadline under the Canada-Newfoundland and Labrador Canada-Wide Early Learning and Child Care Agreement. To support the need for more early childhood educators, the government implemented an early childhood educator wage grid, increasing salaries for all levels based on training and experience.
Financial incentives included a wage grid bonus for administrators and an allowance for early childhood educators and administrators in Labrador. Initiatives to enhance early childhood educator training have also been implemented.
How much is child benefit in the Netherlands in 2024?
The third quarter of 2024 child benefit amounts will be disbursed on October 1, 2024. For children aged six and twelve, the payment will increase in accordance with their respective ages. The amount of child benefit is stated on a per-child, per-quarter basis and is paid subsequent to the conclusion of each quarter.
What is the ratio for daycare in the UK?
To ensure child safety, it is recommended to have at least two adults present when working with or supervising children and young people. The minimum adult to child ratios are under 2 years, 2-3 years, 4-8 years, 9-12 years, and 13-18 years. However, depending on the needs and abilities of the children and the activity, more adults may be needed. Even with smaller groups, it is essential to have at least two adults present.
What is the ratio for 1 year olds in daycare?
Federal law mandates states and territories to establish standards for child group sizes and staff-to-child ratios for child care centers. Infants under 12 months old should have one adult caring for no more than three infants, toddlers between 13-35 months old should have four adults caring for no more than four toddlers, and preschoolers aged 3 years old should have one adult caring for no more than seven preschoolers. These standards ensure the safety, well-being, and development of children in child care programs, allowing them to develop social skills through consistent interaction with a smaller group.
How much do childminders charge per day?
Childminder costs vary depending on the hours worked and location. In London, the average hourly rate is around £7, but this can vary significantly. Parents may also need to consider extras like food, nappies, and wipes. Koru Kids Home Nurseries offer an all-inclusive fee of £79 for a ten-hour day, with a maximum of three children per adult. This makes budgeting simple. Childminders are registered, allowing parents to claim government support, such as tax-free childcare of up to 20 off their bill or funded hours for over threes.
What is the hourly rate for daycare in the Netherlands?
The Dutch government sets a maximum hourly rate for childcare in the country, which has increased from 9, 12 euros in 2024 to 10, 25 euros in 2024. The allowance covers a family’s childcare costs based on the number of children, childcare type, and parents’ taxable income. The higher the parents’ income, the less allowance they receive. However, childcare organizations often set their own hourly rates, which are often higher than the government’s maximum, leaving it up to parents to pay the difference.
How much is the daycare allowance in the Netherlands?
The childcare allowance is calculated based on the government’s maximum hourly rate, which starts at €9. 65 for day care and preschool and €8. 30 for after-school care from January 1, 2024. The difference between these rates and KinderRijk’s rate is for the individual’s account. The Parliament has proposed an increase in these rates, with the Ministry of Social Affairs and Employment working on an urgent amendment. The maximum hourly rates for all childcare types will be increased by 2.
95 above the current average rate, bringing day care and preschool rates to €10. 25 and after-school care to €9. 12. The Tax Authority has incorporated these adjustments into the advance payment for January 2024, and parents will receive childcare allowances starting from December 2023.
How much do most daycares pay per hour?
As of September 2, 2024, the mean hourly wage for a childcare worker in California is $15. 98, with salaries ranging from $11. 63 (25th percentile) to $17. 07 (75th percentile) within the state. ZipRecruiter reports salaries ranging from $29. 89 to $7. 59.
📹 CBC Vancouver News at 6, Sept. 12 – B.C. will scrap consumer carbon tax if Ottawa drops requirement
Watch CBC Vancouver News with host Dan Burritt for the latest on the most important news stories happening across B.C. …
When I was a Christian, I used to volunteer on Sundays. I received a mean email IN CAPS telling me that if I was going to call out I was responsible for finding my own replacement. I was also instructed to park in the dirt lot and leave the close parking spaces for “guests”. I never volunteered again.
“We need to obey the 10 Commandments!” Ok, so we need to keep the Fourth Commandment too? “No, the Sabbath is the Old Law, Christians don’t have to keep the Sabbath.” But keeping the Sabbath is one of the 10, don’t you have to keep all 10? “Yes, we have to keep all 10 Commandments, that’s God’s eternal, universal moral law.” So you DO have to keep the Fourth Commandment. “No, Sabbath keeping is the Old Law…” I’d love to hear one of these guys try to explain this one under rules where they’re not allowed to call it “keeping the Sabbath” and are required to call it “keeping the Fourth Commandment.”
my mother does her laundry on sunday and sunday only out of pettiness, because when she was younger, her mother (my grandmother bless her soul), got in trouble with the Catholic Church, because she dared to do her laundry on a sunday because she didnt have anything left to wear, that one moment has shaped my mother’s determination to always do laundry specifically on that day forever 😂
I went to a Christian college here in California. It was a brannd new college and there were only 38 students. Almost all of them were dutch and i wasn’t. (I am german, welsh, scottish, irish, english and swedish but not dutch) I was completely ignored by the entire campus. Also I wasn’t homeschooled or christian schooled. Two of my three roommates also were not Dutch and we’re not homeschooled or Christian schooled. All three of us were ignored. All three of us left after that first semester. It was terrible. We absolutely hated it because we were ignored by everyone else because we weren’t good enough
As a person who grew up in a Jewish household, this one hits very different. The Sabbath in Jewish tradition is not just you go to church and you take the afternoon off. It’s a sundown to sundown restriction on the ability to carry things with you to use light switches… My brother who’s still a very religious person and a rabbi walk to Temple every Saturday and picks the location that he’s going to live based on how well he’ll be able to walk to Temple from it.
Trevor, thank you for this part of the series! It’s not wrong to choose not to go to church the same way it’s not wrong to choose not go to a school club that you don’t want to be part of. Towards the end of a Christmas mass in 2021, a priest said to everyone that they should try coming to mass more, and that those who don’t need to be more “mindful of their ego”. My BS Detector went off after he said that.
Digging into the 4th commandment as a youth pastor is part of what set me on the path to atheism (also researching what the Bible says happens when you die, but that’s another story). I was like, “isn’t Saturday the Sabbath?” And everybody was like, “oh but Jesus died on a Sunday, so… Yeah it’s that now” and I’m like, “the Bible doesn’t prescribe that, seems like this is honoring the traditions of man over the will of God” and they’re like, “nah, it’s not like that, you see” and then proceeded to talk themselves in circles. In the end I was like, “oh, so this whole thing is just bullshit then I guess”
Sunday you are supposed to rest! Also: On Sunday, you are to wake up early, can’t sleep in, have to travel to church, sit in church for hours, go out to eat (normally) at a place that requires other people TO BE WORKING for you to go to, and are encouraged to then come back in many cases for afternoon service and spend more time there before finally getting home late at night. “Rest” seems to have a different meaning to some people.
As a former Christian I want to thank you so much, once again, for all the hard work you do here. Every so often I get those awful, horrible thoughts about whether or not I was wrong to choose no longer to believe, that I was in sin or going to hell or any number of other things, but I’m so glad every time for all of your articles because wow they really help, more than a lot of others, because of how well it handles apostate things and how much it helps show the hypocrisy and cult-like nature of Christianity in practice. Being an atheist makes me happier than any belief in God ever did.
“I’ve been doing overtime for 3 months.” Try 19. Then try not being able to pay for your food because your bills are too expensive and food is almost double digits for most things. Calling people lazy for not working when they’ve already done so much and destroyed their body for someone who will never thank them is the evil thing.
I knew a guy who grew up in Australia, with parents who had been brought up in the Dutch reformed church in the Netherlands He wasn’t allowed to play sport on the Sabbath as though playing sport is work As soon as he was old enough to leave home he did, and then played lots and lots of sport on the weekend
Not gonna lie, this kinda triggered me a bit. I have ptsd as a combination of a toxic workplace, my church at the time always encouraging me to go above and beyond (in unhealthy ways), AND them asking for me to volunteer time on top of my 70-90 hour work week, raising a family, church services, AND Bible study. I’m sure there’s some people out there who can do it, but not me. Its insane that they push you to work, work, work, and then blame you for working too much, without ever considering any of the reasons, or even just you being tired and sore. Apparently, the line is “Work until it affects the church. You don’t matter.” 🤦♂️
44:10 When I say, “Oh man I’m working a lot.” I’m actually saying, “Sure, I work a normal 40 hours a week, but I also have put in an embarrassing amount of time into Stardew Valley and Skyrim, and no one wants to hear about my crops or my what class my Dovahkiin is, so I’m just going to play off that all my free time is consumed by work and sleep.”
Wow the last rant really hit home. I’m a full time college student with an internship that’s (luckily) only 10hrs a week but also naturally pays only $10/hr in the inner city. I’m always penny pinching and looking for quick gigs and am often told to chill out or rest for a while cause I’m high strung. I don’t work a lot because I want to, I work a lot because if i work any less i can’t eat
I have lived for a short while in Alcalá de Henares, a cmall city in Spain close to Madrid that used to be inhabited by more or less equally large communities of Jews, Muslims and Christians. There I learned that (and I believe this was the case in quite a few places in the Middle Ages) having their holy rest day on different days between religions was actually a really useful practical thing… because it meant that each community could still get their needs met even on the Sabbath day when members of their own community weren’t allowed to work. If a Christian was short on food on Sunday, they could go to a Jewish shop and vice versa.
I am so grateful for your thoughtful, compassionate, and humorous analysis. You give me something to think on and have been pivotal in my journey of deconstructing the self loathing and fear of the world that the christian community beat into me. I can laugh about these things now, often with your articles, and feel less argumentative when I am encountered with a Bible thumping zealot. Now, I just think to myself, “you do you, buddy, but this isn’t for me and it shouldn’t be mandated for anyone.”
So, I grew up as a Seventh Day Adventist. I wasn’t allowed to do anything on the Sabbath (Friday evening on sunset to Saturday on sunset), meaning I had to ostracize myself from friends, miss a regional spelling bee, and just be an all around weirdo when it came to social interactions. Thanks for the section about them being a doomsday cult! It’s definitely true.
I am in a family that makes an entire thing about Sunday. An hour and a half of church, plus commute. Its 45 minutes away from our house, despite the fact that we’re in the deep south and were in WALKING DISTANCE from like EIGHT of them. Then we stay at my grandma’s until 3 in the afternoon and discuss it. There goes half my weekend. Im in IB, I already dont have enough free time. And my parents wonder why i hate church.
15:30 “i dont know what character he’s doing here” i have known actual people like that, my mom used to be like that, it’s the same kind of thing as western people who get into the surface level of eastern spirituality like bhuddism and act like it makes the cultured. there seems to be a similar thing with some Christians look into early bible history and act like they have a deeper understanding than they actually do.
Honestly, I don’t know how I let it get this bad but if you include commute and lunch, I put in 65 hours between two jobs. A day of rest is well appreciated but sometimes I feel bad for only “doing thale bare minimum” or “what everyone else is doing already” Like dawg, wtf. I just want 40 hour work weeks that can afford a life’s wage. Shoot, I’d keep the second job for the employee discount. But only five days a week and 40-45 hours to work would be stellar. And these pastors call me ungrateful and unholy. Uh huh, sure bud. Get your second Cadillac to drive to your ivory coated church in.
I really appreciate your articles and the way they deconstruct the doctrines of evangelical Christianity and point out the issues and inconsistencies. Sometimes I can get tired of hearing the same apologetics be debunked over and over again, but your articles feel less like just debunking apologetics and more about breaking down the actual teachings of Christianity in a way that shows the ways they’re harmful, even the things that may sound nice, and how often they contradict each other or just don’t make sense once you think about them. The way you approach things has helped me recognize and work towards breaking out of the thought patterns that I learned being raised evangelical, instead of still thinking about and approaching things the same way I did as a Christian, just without believing in God. It’s honestly really healing to hear it all broken down and explained this way.
I’m someone with hidden disabilities & for me it does annoy me when I see that some people who are actually lazy & especially if they either manipulate others into doing the work for them or use misogyny to get out of doing something. That being said, that doesn’t mean that people still don’t struggle & need help. Rather than shame people or looking down upon people just because they don’t “look disabled,” maybe we as a society should call people out when they are taking advantage of others or are trying to get out of responsibilities such as using weaponized incompetence as that is what some people use against people with disabilities especially hidden disabilities to tell us that we’re faking it or lying about our disabilities just because they can’t see them or our struggles
I never understood the “Keep the Sabbath” because my family was SUPER involved with the church, so Sundays were a busy day of working from 7 until at least lunch as they ran music, sunday school, gathered up volunteers for other things, etc. So it felt like other people got to rest, but the people making the service happen weren’t allowed. So it just seemed like something that clearly wasn’t important. I mean, if it was actually important, then surely one of the several pastors we had would have told everyone to stop volunteering and actually rest… right? Right?!
I think this is the first time I’ve heard you talk about your parents’ Dutch heritage! It makes me relate your experience even more because my grandparents were immigrants from the Netherlands to a Dutch Christian Reformed community in Eastern Illinois and Northwest Indiana. It’s really interesting to hear about parallel communities that formed and held similarly puritanical values.
Another excellent article. Really appreciate your website…. It is well done and thought provoking. We really need critical thinkers now more than ever. These pastor people are downright creepy. Maybe it’s the absence of any critical thinking at all that is the scariest. Really hope this ancient superstitious propaganda, and all of its distracting, crippling BS are gone one day soon so we can come together without judgement or hate.
I refuse to acknowledge Sunday as the first day of the week. For my entire life I’ve been going to school and the first day of class is always Monday. For me that makes Monday the first day of the week. Plus we call it the weekend, not the weekends so why wouldn’t the two days of the weekend be the end of the week? I’ve never understood this.
Some keep the Sabbath going to Church – I keep it, staying at Home – With a Bobolink for a Chorister – And an Orchard, for a Dome – Some keep the Sabbath in Surplice – I, just wear my Wings – And instead of tolling the Bell, for Church, Our little Sexton – sings. God preaches, a noted Clergyman – And the sermon is never long, So instead of getting to Heaven, at last – I’m going, all along. -Emily Dickinson
I actually have a couple of cousins that are Christian but they do the Jewish traditions. They do passover and Hannica (might not be spelled right) and they don’t eat pork or catfish and shit. They worship on Saturday, they shut off their business on Saturdays, they’re really devout. The rest of the family thinks they’re weird, but I appreciate the fact that they’re consistent.
Here in Argentina at the beggining of the 20th century, there was the debate of wich day workers should have for rest. The conservartive oligarchs reluctanly agree but with the condition that it would be the day that the employers chose. THe socialist congressmen (extreme atheist btw) argue that it should be the same day for everyone since you could have multiple members in one family that work and they wouldn’t be resting the same day. So they propose Sunday since is the traditional day for religious services for the catholic majority of the population. The oligarchs (many of them extreme catholics) agreed.
23:28 I’ve heard this argument before and my answer has always been “then why do we (back when I was still a Christian) have to follow the ten commandments anyway? also, why should we read the Old testament anyway? that’s all the old stuff, it’s obsolete it doesn’t it doesn’t apply anymore.” Their only answer is that it is the word of God so we should follow it, but like the word of God also says that that word is obsolete so which is it?
I have a very sweet Christian woman who takes care of me at a medical clinic I attend. I’ve asked her a few things-like these very questions. Why have Christians rejected all the OT directives when Jesus said he came to uphold the law? She vaguely gestured at Jesus fulfilling everything. I let her be-in this case(and her incredibly kind and decent manner), I don’t need to challenge her further
21:33 “Which the Roman………nation……adhered to.” Try again, Mark. You’re talking about the dictates of an empire. You’re doing what you’re doing because Daddy Rome told you to. I don’t care that your Sabbath is on Sunday instead of Saturday, but I think it’s funny that you seemed to avoid admitting it was because Rome told you to. Does that make you Catholic? Oh man, you are worried that deep down you’re Catholic, aren’t you? It’s unexpected gold like this that makes these articles so rewarding.
28:30 Holy shit he just proved a theory I’ve had for a while: Mark Driscoll thinks he’s god. Not like, delusional, where he thinks he is actually Jehovah, but that whatever he thinks is correct and good is something that god thinks is correct and good. “Wow, look at you guys. You lazy people with your two days off. I only take ONE day off a week because that’s all I need. BTW it’s also what god wants so maybe you should suffer with me- I mean him, too.”
Small world, most of my family is from Ostfriesland, in Friesian I think, Astfraislund? Basically northwest Germany. My grandfather wrote a book about our family called “From the Fields of Friesland” Apropos of nothing, just thought it was cool you mentioned your family is from Friesia. Fun fact: Apparently in Germany, people used to make jokes about people from Ostfriesland in a similar way to people in America used to make jokes about Polish people: “How many Friesians does it take to change a lightbulb? 3, one to hold the bulb and two to spin the ladder.” Don’t be racist y’all.🙃 Good article, thanks for sharing.
Remember yall, leviticus (that may even be mistransplated) also speaks of mixed fabric, shrimp and planting 2 different crops next to each other. If u are genuinely using this book to argue that some ppl shouldn’t be married, you should also be equally mad about media showing people wearing jeans and a coat, that people are being served shrimp in restaurants, that a farmer planted peppers next to their tomato’s. If you don’t think any of this are an actual issue cuz they aren’t serious things that hurt anyone, then why do u care that 2 adults are kissing? Either go all the way, and be amish, or extend the “it’s just a metaphor it’s a minor sin, it was written by people who didn’t know better” to human rights as well, whatever you do, just be consistent.
The incredible irony here of people that say they must keep the sabbath day holy and for god… then go out to Applebees after church forcing someone else to not keep the sabbath day holy…. and then not even tipping them for making them sin because they gave all their tip money in the tithing basket
@22:47 The idea that God gave the Israelites one day off per week and they were immensely grateful because they’d never gotten any time off makes God sound like a manipulative fuck. It’s like a billionaire buying the cheapest instant noodles he can find and giving it to starving children so he can hear them sing his praises when he could easily buy them much better food. (Yes, I understand Bronze Age shepherds couldn’t have afforded to take off more than one day a week, but that’s not the point. And anyway, God could’ve uplifted them to Star Trek and beyond if he wanted to.)
The most ironic thing about the Sabbath day is that most Christian denominations is that the believe Sabbath is Sunday but actually Sabbath is Saturday and the Catholic church overruled that teaching and said “Sabbath is Sunday”. This is an obvious sign that religious scripture is just made up and can change at the whims of church leaders, even things as “important” as the interpretation of the ten commandments, even to the point that some denominations change the interpretation to mean whatever they want, like more religious fundamentalists will say that “you’re doing sabbath wrong if you only just take rest and not go to church and pray”. Then when you point the cruel stuff that God was inflicting on innocent living beings and humans in OT they would say “this is OT idiot!” but then on the same breath say “the ten commandments are important!”. It is very confusing when they cherry pick the “good stuff” and what teachings align with their beliefs and disregard everything else, especially with the OT stuff.
I loved the starship comment! Captain Kirk was so right, in that scene. It’s also the scene from the Star Trek TOS films that most makes me think of the original series episodes. So many of those episodes had hidden “there is no God” messages. I only fully noticed that after deconverting, though. Before that I just squirmed uncomfortably in my seat while my unconcious mind understood all of the subtext that I couldn’t allow myself to see.
Kia ora from New Zealand. When I was at the Roman Catholic Boys School. Religions Study was the one class I skipped it .even today 30 years later I keep religions time to an hour a month a bare minimum after over 30 years of not going to church. Yes I’m an R.C and still think that Christianity has alot to answer for so many things. Ps God party hard on the night of the 6th and was hungover on the 7th
fucking loving the guy at 10:08 who’s like “Oh i’m a fellow struggler, teaching from a position of weakness, i’m so fucking weak and such a failure. For failing to not work on sunday” “i KNOWWW! SO HORRIBLE! I CANT BELIVE I JUST HAVE TO ALWAYS BE PRODUCTIVE AND AWESOME EVERY DAY EVEN SUNDAYYY!” like jesus nonexistant christ my guy you could’ve just not implied you were struggling if you couldnt manage it without turning it into a brag.
As someone who was born and raised Buddhist, this never made sense to me. “Is it sunday? is it Saturday?” They’re just days. I went to religious events on either day, sure Sundays were always bigger days but alot of people were former Christians so they still had that ingrained in them. But it wasn’t a sin to miss a day, you had a life and the truest temple is inside you. Being spiritual was enough.
Thank you for your pitch to unregistered voters, and also a reminder that the United States has other elections in November besides the presidential one! We need both of those messages repeatedly frequently. Great article topic, thank you – growing up as Southern Baptist, we were expected to follow the 4th Commandment, but there was just never any discussion of what that actually entailed. P.S. I most definitely do not endorse the posting of the 10 Commandments (especially the “abridged version” normally used), unless teachers and students in public schools are allowed to engage intellectually with the commandments, question and debate their meaning and significance, and be allowed to compare them with American legal traditions and, in general, explore them like any other school subject. No religious indoctrination in public schools – because in the current uses being proposed, that’s exactly what is intended by the “10 Commandments” proponents.
I grew up Seventh Day Adventist, definitely a doomsday cult – but it was late in life that I figured out the true purpose of this Sabbath. You have to remember that Israelites were a slave owning people… yeah the people who were slaves in Egypt now slave owners… but I digress. Slave owners realized that in order for slaves to be efficient, they couldn’t work them to death, they needed to give them at least one day off. The Sabbath was a way to continue to control slaves on their one-day off- this is why the clause “nor thy man -servant, nor thy maid-servant”. So the slaves could not use that day to improve their quarters, do their own laundry, or do side-work. But you do not have to go to ancient Hebrews to see examples of this. All you need to to is go down to Mt Vernon, to the plantation of the slave-owning “father of our nation”, whose work ethics made sure his slaves worked from sunup to sundown. These slaves had to construct their own cabins on his property, and they could only do it during hours of darkness. They were forbidden to do it on Sunday, their one day off, since George Washington kept it as his Sabbath.
I used to do yardwork for an old couple a handful of years back, and one of the frustrating things was that they refused to let me come over to work on Sundays. I had a full time job mon-fri, and would sometimes be there til 7 or 8 at night. So some weeks the only day I could do any work at their place would be Sunday. And then they’d be upset that their lawn wasn’t mowed for a week and a half. Sure I understood the reasoning, being and ex-christian myself, but you can’t be mad that I could mow your lawn then.
OMG could really relate to the Frisian parent part. I was so used to hearing the phrase “godverdomme”!!! which my conspiratorial and religious mother would never tell me what the translation was. The only big difference is that my Dutch family side has apparently never been religious at all and it’s been an American influence.
31:26 this part really hit me, like your dad I also have rheumatoid and osteoarthritis. some days are better than others but for the most part i deal with so much chronic pain. despite that, i also put on a brave face and try to suck it up, but im sure many people would just say im taking from the government, that i dont deserve disability (which i havent even gotten on yet btw, i applied in march last year and IM STILL WAITING), and also seeing politicians who want to get rid of these programs is fucking scary. i am only 23 years old, im going to be dealing with this for the rest of my life and its already bad, i just am glad that i do not have to go to church or am religious, or have to deal with people who say these things everyday.
At the 32 min mark, a good question may be is laziness a disability? Because if your brain you have makes it very hard to get work done, then what is that? Is it really a choice ? Also, wtf is that guy doing for 60 to 70 hrs a week working for the church? Is he helping old lady’s figure out what email is ?
man the whole damned if youre lazy and humble bragging about struggling with this commandment messed me up so bad. ive been struggling with severe mental health issues my whole life, and its so frustrating to constantly be told that the day of rest is because humans have limits and its holy to rest, and meanwhile every other day of the week im degraded for not doing enough.
Woooow, it’s wild how much grift the pastors push for. Dont take care of yourself, give your time to the church. Tired, burned out, exhausted? Nah you’re just lazy. I left religion over a decade ago, but unpacking this is so helpful. Thank you for posting this article. My family drank this flavorade/lesson hook line and sinker. Its so toxic especially to people who have silent health issues. Don’t listen to your body, you gotta give even more to the church to get blessed. Youre not praying hard enough…. omg fuckin con artists! Way to call them out ❤
@~27:25, RE: Working six days a week. “Those who toil and live in want all their lives are taught by religion to be submissive and patient while here on earth, and to take comfort in the hope of a heavenly reward… Religion is a sort of spiritual booze, in which the slaves of capital drown their humanity, their demand for a life more or less worthy of man.” United we bargain, divided we beg. For the Union makes us strong. Solidarity forever ✊
i think my first red flag for my church was when i asked my pastor “wait so if your job is basically teaching us the word, why do you do it always every sunday, when we are commanded not to work” and he laughed it off and basically said him preaching isnt work but a call to duty, which, is what anyone could call their work? god called me to do woodworking, id still be a fucking woodworker
While I was a devout Catholic I did try to “keep the Sabbath” as that’s what we were told to do as well but it was nowhere as strict as how your Dutch Reformed church did it, besides Jehovah’s Witnesses and Evangelicals I was also familiar with Seventh Day Adventists and their arguments about how the Catholic Church was of Babylon (as per usual) as well as how the Sabbath was changed to Sunday (and our counter argument was that it was because Jesus was supposed to have risen on a Sunday but I never thought much about the specifics). Honestly this is probably the commandment I have the least problem with (regardless of when the Sabbath is supposed to happen) but I’m reminded of one of the crazy priests I used to listen on this site and one time like Driscoll he was complaining about the French Revolution in general and how when the revolutionaries tried to replace the Gregorian calendar with their own everything got out of hand and even cattle started dying for being overworked or something, I think he was trying to prove that the earth was created on seven literal days and that the Sabbath was part or nature’s laws or something. 35:35 he really said the quiet part out loud there, I used to look down on Evangelicals in particular as simpletons because of their anti-intellectualism (while being a pseudo-intellectual myself by thinking that guys like Thomas Aquinas had all the answers to life’s questions) and I’ve heard that anti-intellectualism is particularly bad in denominations like the Churches of Christ, I guess this guy doesn’t believe in higher education?
With the story you told with people from church getting mad at your family for shopping on a sunday kinda shows that almost everyone works the mandated 6 days and people should not be shamed because they get a weekend because often times that weekend is just when you do all the work in the home home needs gets done. It’s disgusting what these pastors are saying and these “hard worker” (the pastors) need a reality check
I like how God only rested on the 7th day as an example for us to follow, yet he gets really pissed any time people do LITERALLY ANYTHING to try to be like him. Knowledge of good and evil? Bad. Working together and building great things? Bad. Trying to understand anything he hasn’t explicitly told us? Bad. Making laws and moral judgements when God’s are insufficient? Bad. Determine your own purpose and value? Bad.
Ryan Visconti is so incredulous that people would doubt that God created the world in just six days. My question is, why would it have taken that long? Augustine famously believed that the six days were purely symbolic because in his mind it was ridiculous to think God didn’t create instantaneously… because he’s God. Also what would be the point of God resting “as an example?” No one who could have consciously appreciated the example even existed when he started creating, so how would they have known he wanted them resting every seventh day? Also also, what does God using his hands or changing his mind represent if those things are purely anthropomorphisms? How are we to know anything about God if all the language we use to describe God’s actions are not true or accurate?
Saturdays in old Norse society where meant for washing clothes and have baths, which partly sounds like a day of rest from heavy work. Saturdays where called “lögardagen” which was later on shortened to “lördag.” I generally think it’s good to have days of rest but I don’t think it should matter when it happens. Much of society has changed and with it we have a lot of institutions or companies that would fall apart if everyone everywhere would follow the sabbath rule. People can still get in accidents, there could be a fire or someone’s doing crime and someone has to be there no matter what day it is… These places would be heavily affected: Hospitals, funeral homes, elder homes, mental health institutions, police forces, fire brigades, grocery stores, technicians, buses, trains, cleaners, travel agencies and hotels.
I always laugh when someone says, “Sunday is the day of rest.” How is it the day of rest? Getting showered, shaved, putting on fancy clothes, getting everyone in a car, driving to a church, and missing your favorite shows is a day of rest? That sounds like a lot of work to me. A day of rest–in my eyes–would kicking off my shoes and relaxing in bed for an 8 hour nap. THAT would be a day of rest. Not hustling and bustling early in the morning so we can make it to church.
having grown up with the “judaizing” (??) christians that the guy was talking about. i can only imagine he’s being super racist about traditions he thinks are weird. i won’t pretend messianic judaism makes sense as a coherent religious belief, and it definitely messed me up. but people aren’t adopting it for the novelty, they think that modern christianity has watered down certain biblical ideas and festivities. it comes from a paranoia of being forgotten or left behind as the chosen people. again i won’t pretend it made a ton of sense to me, but the way the guy talked about it just seemed racist and left a bad taste in my mouth. it’s not a novelty, or a fun thing for these people to “judaize” things. it’s crazed older evangelicals clinging to being the chosen people.
I’m repulsed and fascinated by John Hagee’s voice/speaking style. I mean, he’s pompous, obviously, but there’s something else… I can’t decide if he sounds really constipated, or if he sounds like he’s desperately trying to not shit his pants. He’s pompously not shitting his pants. It’s amazing—he sounds like both opposites at the same time!
Like the Temple was destroyed and temple worship ended, So was the Seventh day from Creation. the Romans made a ten days week that ended the Sabath. We now remember the resurection of our Lord and like early Christians did. We need to set a day in the week apart to remember Jesus’s Dead and Resurection.
Haven’t watch the whole article yet so apologies if you cover this, but it just occured to me that pastors do the majority of their job on the Sabbath. Every week. I’m sure they get around it by saying they still keep it holy by preaching the word of God, but the commandment is very clear they aren’t supposed to work and they do
I was raised Catholic, and looking back I can see that this is one of those issues that exposes how the average believer doesn’t really know anything about the history of it, and they’ll just make up stuff to make it make sense in their own minds. In one of the very early grades in Catholic school, I remember someone asking “why does it say the seventh day but Sunday is the first day of the week?”, and instead of getting into the history, or talking about the word “Sabbath” and what it means, or anything helpful, the teacher said that Monday used to be the first day of the week. Additionally, I’ve heard some Christians say that Saturday is the Jewish Sabbath and Sunday is the Christian Sabbath. The phrase “Christian Sabbath” is nonsensical and displays a powerful lack of comprehension.
I got genuinely angry when that pastor said we decided weekends off because of some debate about when the sabbath is. I shouldn’t be surprised though because our education system intentionally buries the history of unions (along with contributions from minorities, origins of discriminatory practices, etc).
From a young age I was always bewildered by the “Sabbath/Sunday” debate, and as I got older it started to annoy me more and more. Why? Because I realized that calendars and the arrangement of days, weeks and months is entirely created by humans, and different in various cultures. In a system (one week = 7 days) what does it matter when or where it begins? How can it have a “first” day at all? It’s just a counting system. If you work for six days and keep one day “holy” in terms of the 4th Commandment – that seems like plenty. How do we make something so simple so hard?
You ever have someone explain something to you so confidently and have it be so objectively incoherent that you just kinda nod you head, smile and walk away? That’s how I feel when Christians explain the sabbath being Sunday and how the trinity works. Not to mention that whole thing about Jesus being fully god and fully human. Religion is the only thing I know of that can get people to collectively proclaim impossible things so confidently, all the while acting like they are doing you a favor.
Funny things come up when comparing how it’s taught in US vs how I was taught in school in Europe, specifically Poland. Over here the translation went “remember to celebrate the holy day”, as Sunday is in fact first day of the week according to church, as everyone knows Jews celebrate Sabbath on Saturday. (which even is root word for our word for Saturday: sobota) I remember asking question I don’t think I ever got answers to as to why Christians celebrate Sunday as day off, where old testament that Jews follow, points to Saturday. Also we do not have the one about the idols in our translation, so this is 3rd one for us, instead the lest one is split to 9th “not desire a wife of your ‘brother'” and 10th “…or any thing belonging to them”. but whatever
Am I the only one who gets very confused when people say Sunday is the beginning of the week? I remember for most of my life that the week goes from Monday to Sunday. Then about a year ago everyone around me started saying the week was Sunday to Saturday. Is this a Bernstein Bears thing or did I miss something for my whole life?
And Moses came down from the mountain carrying three tablets and addressed the Tribes of Israel. “The Lord has given unto you these Fifteen Commandments!” At which point Moses drops and shatters one of the tablets. “Uh, these Ten Commandments!” If you can for the next commandment article play this clip of Mel Brooks’ “History of the World, Part I.”
The amount we could achieve in America if on Sunday, instead of cult worship, tens of millions of people took time to rest or help someone in need or learn something actually useful to help themselves or their community. The mental health epidemic would be far less of a problem, poverty would plummet, bigotry would plummet, it would be incredible.
“You get more days off than God.” Western culture needs to address the fact that not all employment is work. If you have to show up on a Sunday to boss people to do the labor, you aren’t working that hard, are you? Or let’s say you don’t even really work, you simply own the business and someone else manages it. If you show up, are you working? Not unless you want to. I can’t be the only one to have a boss who took the trash out once a week, made sure it was in sight if everyone and then went back to social media and Minecraft on the computer for the rest of the week (because they sometimes forget to put mute back on and we hear noises from these things).
My mom drank this kool-aid so hard. Saturday we had to clean the church then get up before dawn(in winter) to go to the early service… we then had to wait for her to leave choir and clean up after. Ffs… the rhetoric alone in this article growing up made me question the sanity of the people around me.
Keep the Sabbath holy until… -you have a heart attack and need an ambulance and go to the hospital to let the heathens take care of you -you have an elderly or disabled family member to take care of -your kids are puking their guts out and you need to do laundry -you get hungry and notice that your fridge is empty -you have to work multiple jobs to support you and your household -there is a natural disaster and you have to help your community recover a basic standard of living -or basically any other emergency that can’t wait for an arbitrarily chosen day to pass. In my youth group, our leaders were big proponents of following the spirit of the law vs. the letter of the law. For example, they made it a point to explain communion as a symbolic commitment that could be done with any mix of ingredients… They used the example of mountain dew and Oreos. I will never forget that. 😂 Don’t get me wrong, they were extremists in many other ways, but they seemed to understand that in today’s world, life isn’t that simple and you can be a good Christian without being ultra legalistic.
I grew up in Evangelical Christianity that had what is called Progressive Dispensationalism, so in short that meant we followed the New Testament rules and not the Old Testament laws. That is how we “dealt with” the weird commands like not growing two different crops in the same field. It also meant that the 4th commandment was unnecessary for Christians but we still needed to worship Jesus on Sunday because that was the day of the week he rose from the dead. Now all this seems like the kind of confusion only a collection of books that contradict each other could cause. 😂
Wait just one minute! Aren’t there Christian schools that they can send their children? I mean, those people ran and took their children and put them in private Christian schools, when the government instituted Brown v Board of Education. + They are not following the 613 Commandments to the letter. Anyway, I always look forward to seeing your articles, thanks for sharing.
I am so confused because foe me subday IS the 7th day of the week. Calendar starts on mondays. The week number starts on monday too (for example for 2024 the fist week of the year starts on monday January first). I mean saturday and sunday are called the weekend because its the end of the week. Is that an american thing ? I am french for reference.
His tone was icky, but the term “judaizers” is a pretty standard term used by commentators on the New Testament, both Christians and scholars. It refers to the faction that we see Paul in conflict with in his letters, especially Galatians. These were Jewish Christians most likely associated with the church in Jerusalem who disapproved of Paul’s message that the gentiles could be saved by faith without following the law and went around to churches he had planted trying to get new gentile converts to be circumcised and keep kosher and whatnot. These are the people of whom Paul was like, they like circumcision so much, I wish they’d go the rest of the way and chop the whole thing off!
The implication of the priesty boys in this one is pretty clear, and pretty despicable, in a late-stage capitalist world where leisure is a rarity, dedicate what little you do have to them and their invisible friend, because you aren’t allowed to actually have any time to yourself, got to twist yourself in knots to make it about giving them time to bilk you with the collection plate and chances to neg you.
Three things. One, when calculating payroll for a 7 day week, using the Sumerian Base 60 time keeping system, 1/7th seems to result in an unending series of numbers past the decimal point. It would be simpler to not calculate the seventh day of the workweek. Two, most translations of 1 Timothy 3:2, and Titus 1:6 invoke that only having one wife is to be above reproach. The New Testament does clearly favor one wife or partner, if not entirely celibate. Myths of “one true love” and “love at first sight”, the fabled “one that got away”, and the vow of “til death do we part”, are more apropos. Three, Revelation 17:9-11 is interesting when discussing the Sabbath. There is an eight, which was, is not, and is going to its destruction. So take the 8, and turn it sideways, ∞. So now we have a woman sitting on the 6th, of a scale of 1-7 that is also 1-∞, repeating weeks on a calendar, a never ending story?
For years sometimes I had to work on sundays due to that was the rotation con my job. My Pastor never said anything, just that he lamented me not being able to attend every sunday. Some sundays we would have a short service and dedicate some hard cleaning or construction work at church where we would have lunch together (my church is small, no more than 100 members). Seriously I don’t understand being a zealot about the “Sabbath”. Of course is good to have a free day on sundays but really? Jesus said it clearly, if what you are doing on that day does not contradict the law, what is the problem? I’m from Argentina btw.
Ok real talk. Are these pastor’s apart of some organization that gives them bullet point sermons? Forgive me if you’ve confirmed this explicitly at some point, but they really do follow the same exact sermons beat for beat every time (or at least this particular set does). Heck, despite my disdain for them in general, it doesn’t even bother me that much; I just really want to know.
The debate between “Saturday” and “Sunday” being the “Seventh Day” is kind of odd to me. I understand there’s a historical reason, I believe dating back to the Hebrew Calendar, however, Saturday and Sunday being labeled as the “Weekend” to me just means “END OF THE WEEK” I prefer calling Sunday the seventh day of the week, and therefor Sunday is the Seventh Day.
so, im currently at about the 37:00 mark in this article, and this whole bit about seven literal days or not and what they do and dont take literally reminded me one one of the things i find most confusing about the church’s response to science. Because growing up i was told that 1. god is all powerful, he can do anything, etc and 2. that god doesnt tell us everything. and you would think that these two premises would make it rather easy to reconcile science with one’s religious beliefs, right? oh the bible says X but science says Y? well god created everything so obviously Y is correct and he just opted not to tell us then. why? who effing knows, hes god. like, reconciling science with your religious beliefs should be easier than going about it in the opposite direction, right? but for some reason, if you suggest this as a possibility, you’re told that we can’t know and we’re not supposed to speculate and whatever, but like, why? thats probably what led to some of my earliest doubts about the church
… So we’re just gonna ignore that fella in Deuteronomy who got stoned to death because he was passing by a field on the Sabbath and idly brushing his hand along the wheat (as you do) and was eating the wheat berries that fell into his hand … Because they considered THAT to be/working/ on the Sabbath? It’s like Deuteronomy doesn’t even exist unless they’re trying to hate somebody.
Let’s say we 100% know that the sabbath needs to be the 7th day and we can’t arbitrarily choose a consistent day. How do we know when that day is? Does anyone have a calendar that dates back to the creation? Any day of the week we choose is a guess. Yes Saturday is the 7th day of the modern calendar. But who thinks Adam and Eve kept an accurate record and it’s been passed down without error for 6-10k years? And that assumes you believe in a young earth. If you believe the universe is 14 billion years old it’s even more ludicrous to know which day is the 7th. ANY choice of sabbath is arbitrary.
Also, a lot of this reasoning rests on the “fact” that sunday is the first day of the week, and saturday the seventh. But this is also totally arbitrary and not consistent across different countries. In most of europe, monday is counted as the first day of the week. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Week#/media/File:First_Day_of_Week_World_Map.svg
One of the pastors mentions a study done in France and Russia where they tried to not do a 7-day work week and it didn’t work, I wanna see this study. Does anyone know where I can read more on this? … I love the Douglas puppet hate. Still, Douglas is better than Psalty The Singing Songbook which is what I grew up with. Trust me, you don’t wanna watch Psalty, I really wish the Men In Black would erase the Psalty memories from my mind. My parents wouldn’t let me watch Veggietales as they thought the Veggietales were satanic, I think that is ironic.