Homeschooling is a controversial topic that raises questions about children’s right to a meaningful education and protection from potential abuse. Critics argue that there is little legal oversight of educational standards or safeguards against abuse, and that homeschooling provides children with a safe learning environment. However, research shows that homeschooled children perform above average in terms of academic achievement, social and emotional development, and success into adulthood.
Homeschooling allows parents to have greater control over their children’s education and gives them more time to teach good morals. However, the ethical justification for homeschooling is complex, as the sources of information may be limited and students can be heavily biased. Homeschooling is an inherently deficient form of education that is morally permissible only as long as public schooling is even worse.
Proponents argue that homeschooling provides customization, flexibility, stronger familial bonds, and freedom from negative social pressures of traditional schools. However, Bartholet’s legal argument is that homeschooling is an infringement on child rights, placing children in inferior, socially isolating, and dangerous situations. Ideological echo chambers are likely to form when students are shielded from diverse experiences.
Despite these concerns, some research suggests that homeschooled children’s moral reasoning is at least as advanced as that of other children. The debate surrounding homeschooling continues, with scholars like Michael W Apple critiquing homeschool parents’ desires to cocoon their children.
📹 Homeschoolers Have a Leg Up in Developing Social Skills. Here’s Why
Interacting with all different ages is better preparation for real life! As soon as we finish school we need to get along with people …
Does Harvard accept homeschoolers?
Harvard College treats all applicants, including homeschooled ones, equally and welcomes all relevant information about their educational and personal background. The admission application requirements apply to both first-year and transfer applicants, and are the same for domestic and international applicants. The Common Application and Coalition Application by Scoir are accepted, and both are treated equally by the Admissions Committee.
To ensure full and timely consideration, applicants must complete and submit their materials as soon as possible, with portions due by November 1 for Restrictive Early Action and January 1 for Regular Decision. High school counselors have an additional week to submit materials on behalf of applicants.
Is homeschooling allowed in the Netherlands?
The Netherlands’ education system is compulsory, with most schools accepting children from the age of four. Home-schooling is not accepted by the government. Education starts at age five, with partial compulsory education above 16. After obtaining a diploma, schooling ends. Children go to elementary school from age 4-12, with final exams serving as a guide for secondary school selection. Secondary schools, aged 12-16/18, offer different profiles, ranging from vocational to academic focus. Some schools offer mixed profile classes, allowing students to make decisions later.
Are homeschooled students more successful UK?
Homeschooling is a method where a parent takes on the responsibility of providing education for their child, rather than sending them to a school. This approach can be fulfilling for both the child and their family, leading to better academic outcomes and qualifications. Homeschooling does not restrict a young person from attending university or having a fulfilling career. In the US, universities and employers actively seek out home-schooled young people in their recruitment efforts.
UK research has found that home-schooled children develop as well or better socially, emotionally, and psychologically than institutionally-schooled children. In 2023, between 125, 000 and 180, 000 children were homeschooled in the UK, a number that is increasing each year. Homeschooling is gaining momentum and popularity among families as it showcases its success in both academic and social aspects.
What are the three biggest issues in education today?
American children are facing significant challenges, including low reading and math scores, rising mental illnesses, absenteeism, and bullying. School teachers struggle to reach students due to understaffing, low salaries, and scarce resources. The education system has not kept up with modern technology, and while new teaching methods and technologies could improve outcomes, schools are struggling to effectively use them.
Do universities accept homeschooled students UK?
Homeschooling is becoming increasingly popular in the UK, with almost all universities accepting students from homeschool backgrounds annually. Traditional qualifications like AS and A Levels may be easier for students, but some technical degrees, like medicine, architecture, or chemical engineering, may not admit students without A Levels. However, subjects like arts and humanities may be more flexible and accept a portfolio of work, personal statement, or UCAS points derived from other activities.
Some universities may also accept other qualifications in lieu of A Levels, such as B. Techs, foundation degrees, or the International Baccalaureate. UCAS is the most popular method of applying to university in the UK, working on a points-based system, with offers given based on an applicant’s achievement of a certain number of UCAS points.
What is the greatest challenge in school?
Mental health and well-being are among the greatest challenges students face today. Navigating through a complex city can be overwhelming for students, as they must balance academic success with maintaining a healthy personal life. Time management, organization, academic support, and finding purpose and direction are all crucial aspects of a student’s life. Students may carry on too much work between classes, homework, extracurricular activities, and personal life, making it difficult to pinpoint the single greatest challenge they face. Individual experiences and circumstances play a significant role in discerning these challenges.
How much does it cost to homeschool in the UK?
Homeschooling in the UK can cost between £1, 000 and £8, 000 annually, depending on the required materials and resources. The cost may increase if parents hire a tutor or enroll their child in online classes. Homeschooling also incurs costs for books, stationery, and equipment. Parents often hire private tutors to help struggling students, teach those who don’t want to learn, and address their child’s learning needs.
Where is homeschooling most common?
Homeschooling is a popular educational practice in countries like Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the UK, and the US. However, some countries have highly regulated programs, while others, like Germany, outlaw it entirely. In some cases, homeschooling is considered socially unacceptable or undesirable, making it virtually non-existent. Kenya is currently the only country where homeschooling is permitted.
What is the biggest challenge of homeschooling?
Homeschooling can be a challenging environment for children, as it requires parents to find creative ways to keep lessons interesting and engaging. Addressing resistance or lack of interest can be achieved by tailoring education to individual children’s interests. Financial and resource constraints can also pose challenges, as homeschooling materials and resources can be expensive. Finding affordable or free educational resources is crucial, as homeschooling typically costs $600 per student annually.
What is the most common issue for homeschooled children?
Homeschooling can be a beneficial experience for both parents and children, but it can also present unique problems. One common issue is social isolation, which can lead to school withdrawals, loneliness, and lack of motivation. Parents may also experience exhaustion due to their efforts in their children’s education. Although homeschooling generally produces socialized individuals who become productive members of society, it can also create frustration and problems for parents. It is important to remember that loving Christian parents provided an incredible upbringing for the author, but it is essential to address common problems with home education to maintain balance.
What is the biggest disadvantage of homeschooling?
The primary benefits of homeschooling include academic flexibility, personalized learning, stronger family bonds, community engagement, and efficient learning tailored to the child’s needs. The COVID-19 pandemic significantly increased homeschooling rates, which surged from a steady 3. 3 to 11. 1 in the fall of 2021 as schools closed and parents turned to homeschooling as an alternative. Common disadvantages of homeschooling include a lack of real-life socialization, limited access to resources and facilities, the demanding load on parents, and potential legal challenges.
Homeschooled children may have fewer peer-to-peer interactions and less exposure to diverse social environments compared to children in traditional schools. Studies show no significant difference in academic achievement between homeschooled and traditionally schooled children, with both groups performing equally well in areas like reading, math, and science. Homeschooling families may face legal challenges such as varying state regulations and potential scrutiny or restrictions on their ability to homeschool, creating uncertainty and difficulty.
Homeschooling parents often seek out community support groups, online resources, and sometimes hire tutors to supplement their knowledge and provide adequate educational opportunities for their children. Homeschooling can be particularly beneficial for children with special needs, providing a tailored learning environment that meets their specific requirements and supports their development. Some parents choose homeschooling over traditional schooling for various reasons, including concerns about the traditional school environment, the desire for a more personalized education, religious or moral beliefs, and the need to address specific learning needs or challenges.
Parents play a central role in homeschooling, acting as the primary educators and facilitators of their child’s learning. They are responsible for creating a curriculum, providing instruction, and ensuring their child’s educational progress. Homeschooling has been a popular choice for many parents due to its flexibility, personalized learning, stronger family bonds, community engagement, and efficient learning tailored to the child’s needs.
The COVID-19 pandemic has also impacted homeschooling rates, with the surge in homeschooling rates from 3. 3 to 11. 1 in the fall of 2021. However, there are common disadvantages to homeschooling, such as a lack of real-life socialization, limited access to resources and facilities, the demanding load on parents, and potential legal challenges.
📹 What’s The Point of Homeschooling, Anyway?
Seamus and Bob are back! While reading his preferred newspaper, Ron begins to think that banning homeschooling is a great …
You know: I mention this to people all the time about home schoolers. I worked at Disneyland. If you’ve ever worked there, you would know it’s all about sex, partying, and drinking. The only ones who were not apart of this were the homeschoolers. Everyone called them awkward. Yes, they didn’t fit in. Because they weren’t being heathens! They stood up for what was right. They were mature, didn’t make perverted jokes and worked very hard! They cared about the guest at Disney and didn’t care about fitting in.
These are valid points. This is why our main socialization is naturally designed to happen in families, who are people of all ages who care about one another and who look out for each other. The home is where the greatest development is. Another positive check for God, who designed the family! 😊 BTW, this format works for many types of animals, too, such as wolves and elephants and dolphins.
If I have to hear about socialization from non homeschoolers anymore I’m going to go nuts. We are almost approaching 3 mil. Back in the 90s we were 250,000. There are more options than ever if you want to homeschool but I think that parents need to go back to PARENTING. Yes, my kids are sheltered from perversion, since when did sheltering children from perversion become wrong in our society’s eyes? My kids are not socialized to the standards of modern degeneracy, sorry not sorry, that’s my decision and so far I’ve gotten nothing but compliments about it, I’m told my children are a joy. Instead of focusing socializing, I’m focusing on teaching them to be a blessing to the ones around them. They know how to strike up a conversation with anyone, they talk to children and adults alike, and they even know how to interact with babies and toddlers. We are not in a class of the same age and the same people for the majority of our life, I think this is SUCH a stupid argument to make against such an important decision.
I know this. But I’m so burnt out with my 5 year old crazy energetic boy. So I am tossing up the idea of sending him to public kindergarten for 1 year so I can reset. I also have a 1 year old and my husband works 60hrs a week. We live in a rural town and homeschool coops don’t exist and playground meetups are not enough. I feel so sad for even thinking of sending him. The only good thing is that all kindergartens in our state are play based only.
As lovely as all this sounds, I really believe in school as a way of helping your children socially. Kids need each other, other kids outside their family, and it’s good for them to go out and be able to trust a teacher, a teacher that sets limits and challenges them educationally.. as a mum of 4 and a part time teacher, having my kids go to school was wonderful for them and me… Also sometimes mums need a mental break, and turning on the TV so you can tune out is not the best option, having a few hours of kindergarten can so help both mum and kid to have that much needed mental space.. Yes, we do put too much emphasis on performance and not letting kids be kids, but school is stil amazing for kids social development
This commentary skirts around the issue I saw and dealt with as a lead secretary in a university science department – the home-schooled offspring did not know how to interact with people they needed help from, and were ill-prepared for routine life issues. They acted like I was their mother and was supposed to take care of problems for them. As if their home-schooling mothers pandered to their every need. Granted, this may have been the effect of their parent’s religious beliefs – I don’t know. Having to process academic records before they were admitted to our program gave me a unique perspective into the psychological handicap home-schooled people came in with. Very self-centered, and lacking in the basic social skills is what I saw. Others that had good social skills had a very narrow viewpoint of everyday, commonplace words/verbiage that I was at a loss to explain. Before making comments, be aware, I am a staunch cradle-Catholic, who never left the Faith, and attended parochial school.
I live in a family with six other siblings. My parents decided to experiment when it came to schooling. One of my siblings begged to be homeschooled because the public school was not fulfilling their educational needs. He vastly improved under homeschool and is now heading off to college. However, when my mom approached the school and told them her plan. The principal was hostile and cold. The superintendent asked what her reasoning was. She answered that she felt that her son was not getting the educational help he needed. To which the principal said that it was “her job to provide that educational support, not the schools.” My mom responded that she was going to do just that by pulling him out of the school and homeschool him. The superintendent was very helpful in pointing her towards resources, but the principal was antagonistic and initially opposed her.
Homeschooling was awesome! I managed to get a fourth of my Associate’s degree done at 17 through concurrent enrollment, and I believe I was only ready for that workload because of what I learned homeschooling. I plan on using FEE resources as a homeschooling curriculum for my kids later in life. Great stuff all around here!
In Brazil, my country, homescholling is banned since the 30s, when the president Getúlio Vargas wanted to control the education, also creating a federal system to control what can be taught in every school in the country. The system remains the same, and public scholls are awful compared to the private schools (even though public scholls are 2 times more expensive (the gov would pay less to just give the parents the money to put everyone in private schools)) for example, Brazillians public schools have the position 69 in PISA (the avaliation of education between many countries) but the private schools are in the 5th position.
You forgot the most important question,”how can we brainwash your child to be a good little marxist when we can’t get them to ourselves 8 hours a day?”.or “How can we use peer pressure to crush the /I’ll think for myself,review multiple sources and come my own conclusion/types if we can’t control their peer group?”
Hubby and I both went to public and private school. We both ended up with very unsatisfying educational experiences. I’m an accelerated book learner. He’s a slower hands-on learner. I stagnated waiting for my classmates to catch up so we could move on. He slowly got left behind as everyone else passed him by. But he was homeschooled for 3 years and they were the best ones of his education. He could take as much time as he needed and learn in his own way. And he thrived. So we decided early on to homeschool our own kids. That way, however fast they learn, in whatever way they learn, we’ll be meeting their needs right where they are. When our middle son was diagnosed with autism, that clinched it even further. Even his therapist agreed homeschool would be best because he thrives in the one-on-one attention and gets distracted if there are too many other people around. Homeschooling isn’t for everyone. But I think more people should actually try it out instead of just writing it off from the get-go. You might just be surprised.
Former homeschooler here 😁homeschooling is a system where you get out of it what you put into it. The smartest most high achieving kids I knew had very involved parents, whereas the parents that offered less structure and involvement had kids that clearly underperformed. No we are not social pariahs 😊 just find some other activities or a co-op and your kid will be fine.
I’m kind of an edge case. On one hand, for most of my homeschooling, I was lonely, anxious, introverted, and depressed. On the other hand, I was going to “homeschool co-ops” and was sufficiently socialized, and I’ve turned out pretty ok so far, considering I was 1 of 4 homeschooled children, and my father was long dead. So the fact that I’m not a death/crime statistic for kids who grew up in fatherless homes is impressive. Outperforming all most of the public schoolers is nice too.
When I was actually going to public school I thought people weren’t taught a lot because their parents gave them so much free time. But public school literally taught me nothing important and if they did they made it confusing as fuck. Tl;dr- I really wish I was homeschooled, public schools just tries to turn kids into puppets, and succeed most of the time
I remember when I into public school after homeschooling in the 5th grade. Had me take a test to see if I was “educated enough” to be in 5th grade. Made a 100. Vice principal’s response: “There’s no way you made it that high, take it again.” I took it again what do you know? Made 100. Honestly don’t know why this bias even came about against home schoolers. These reasons on here were new to me, except for the scores one. But what really made me laugh during my 5th grade year, was I could read with no problems but everybody else in my class had to still sound out every single word.
What is unexpected to me is that the daughter of a public school teacher home schooled her children (the grandchildren of the school teacher). This daughter seems ‘normal’ and average in other aspects. … I believe in a real education, and believe it won’t come from public schools, which are used to launder money through the teacher’s unions into political campaigns, being turned into day care centers, and even supporting known dangerous children and criminals as was shown by the policies at Parkland. The Parkland shooter was know to be dangerous since kindergarten and had attacked people in high school. The school policies tolerated certain crimes on school property.
Another point id like to make is that several officials on the school board making decisions about curriculum don’t even have a teaching degree or were never teachers themselves. Not saying it should necessarily be a requirement to be put on the school board but promoting or electing teachers could help bring attention to the fundamental issues of the school system. Not to mention the fundamental classroom which was originally designed to help teach skills for factory and labor jobs has remained virtually unchanged for decades
I was homeschooled but didn’t get my GED til i was like 30…i ONLY studied up on math to prep (pointless because NOTHING i studied ended up useful for the test). The teacher was talking to me like I was special needs when i first got there and started on the preliminary test. When I finished it and she checked my score, I saw genuine surprise on her face, she congratulated me and suddenly started talking to me as if I was an adult. I passed the real test with flying colors only except they didn’t like my essay because I wasn’t politically correct. They made us write essays on why we should lower the voting age. I wrote why we shouldn’t.
I get the point about social skills a lot when I tell people I wanna homeschool my future children. I went to public school and am working towards a career that would allow me to work from home. So I see no reason not to homeschool kids. I’ve met homeschooled kids before, most that are done for religious reasons resent the religious side of it but are glad they didnt do public school otherwise. Ivemet many people who would have wanted to be homeschooled due to bullying, education requirements, and inability to thrive in the classroom setting. As someone who was all of the above in school, it is likely my future children would be similar so thus why homeschool is what I’d like to do.
The thing no one seems to point out is that this doesn’t have to be an either or proposition. Even if you can’t homeschool, or want your kids to go public so they can be around kids their own age, why not spend a little extra time tutoring them at home? You’ll find out what they’re being taught and if it’s sensible, you can help them in any areas they’re struggling in, and you can help them focus on subjects they’re actually interested in to prepare them for any higher education they might choose to do later.
If you’re raising your kid to eventually do something like take over your business, them spending 5 days a week in school means they don’t grow up with an understanding of the business. A better system would be 3 days at school, 2 at home to learn for what they’ll actually be doing in life, but this isn’t usually allowed. The alternative is to homeschool, teach them enough from academia to survive, but then give them the actual skills they’ll need. As it currently is with schools, if you want to teach your kid skills for the future not covered by the syllabus, you’re stuck doing it over the weekend (thereby stealing your kid’s rest days) or the evenings (when they’re tired from school), not to mention they’ll also have homework to do. This makes the kid resent the idea of inheriting the business. But if you do homeschooling where you teach them academically in the morning, and teach them the business in the afternoons, or some other combination, they’ll grow up with a better appreciation and skill for actually inheriting. Sure, maybe they won’t get a high grade in music or art, but so what? If they want to be an artist they can still choose to do so later. You instead teach them math, English and science, maybe one or two other subjects, and give them a high quality of business acumen which will serve them far better in the future. But no, can’t do that. Gotta cram all the kids, regardless of intelligence or interest or what they are likely to actually do with their lives, into prisons all week with no time for basically anything else.
I’ve done public, private, charter, and homeschool. The year I was homeschooled was the best year out of all of them. I had so much fun and still had awesome friends, even outside of church. Advice: have your kids do sports or youth groups or other activities where they get to hang out with other kids if you’re still afraid of them becoming a little too awkward.
I’m a teacher in Ontario. Every month we get a magazine as part of our membership (you have to pay to be a teacher, don’t you love government bodies). In this magazine is a section of all disciplinary action taken against member teachers. And every month, for just the province of Ontario alone, we have about 30 cases of sexual misconduct. I wish they’d make this print public so everyone could see how morally superior we teachers are. It’s absolutely ridiculous.
I did amazing in homeschooling, but when put in public school I had extreme anxiety, was bullied horribly, and had to drop out because I was having crippling stomach cramps to the point I had to starve myself just to be able to walk from class to class. I only stayed awake my eating mints. Overall, I had to drop out.
I know this is completely anecdotal, but my public school district was crap. We still had Clinton as the lastest president in our text books, my physics teacher was literally the worst and didn’t anything in class, and the TEA had to completely take over the school board and the superintendent is now in prison for embezzlement. Public schools need to be improved or disolved.
Home schooled all my life. 10 kids in the family and I’m the older of the middle two. My parents did it primarily for religious reasons, but also because preschool was holding my oldest sibling back and he was bored out of his mind. I’d say my parents did subpar in our education (part of the reason for that is the fact that, on average, we moved every 2-1/2 years). I thought most of my friends, also home schooled, were pretty far ahead of me academically. Now that most of my siblings are graduated it’s interesting to see where we are at. One with no collage education works primarily with PHD and Masters graduates. One is an electrician, with some collage as part of the job. One got a BA (easier than he thought) and after several years now works in the field of his major. ect, ect. I think we are doing just fine. Socially, we always had several siblings around, and friends from Church meetings and sport activities (generally home schooled families in both groups). I used to think we might have been socially awkward, till I actually started interacting with kids who were public schooled and realized there wasn’t much of a difference, extroverts were still extroverted and introverts were still introverted.
My son is non-verbal autistic and we’re homeschooling him because where we live has a special ed program that we did not like, plus the covid regulations were both unfeasible for him and would have had him stuck in SE the entire day, no recess, no gym, no seeing neurotypical kids. We also did not like the idea of handing him to the schools when he couldn’t tell us what happened while he was there. He’s a very smart kid who learned to read very young, and he’s very independent and social on his own, but he’s very active and won’t suit still for long, and there was no way he’d just sit and watch a laptop for hours a day. The pandemic has been hard on homeschool families because our normal, out of home routines ended when the libraries and museums closed. Field trips with other homeschool families were canceled, the special needs sports programs were canceled. That’s what’s been hard on us. Public school supporters think homeschool kids never leave the house but we normally do a lot of activities. And the co-ops shut down too. The only positive is that now family who hated him being homeschooled and very very vocal (and horribly rude) about it have left us alone, because now it’s the “safe” option.
I was homeschooled…went to Community College, got an AS in Information Technology, kept that momentum going, and am in my last semester for a BS in Information Technology. And I plan on keeping that momentum going and getting ISACA Certifications. So sick of the ‘weird’ stereotype. If you’re being considered weird, like I was back in high school…take it as an opportunity to make a plan for your life and implement it. When you’re cleaning everyone else’s clock, you’ll thank yourself for being “weird.”
During my high school years I got stuck with a feminist teacher teaching job preparation. I was wondering why my grades were so bad in there so one day when she wasn’t in the room I looked at the grade book. Mostly all the boys had bad grades and mostly all the girls had perfect grades. I reported it to the principle and my mother. I’m not sure if anything came of that, but when I heard I would have to repeat the 12th grade because of her, I chose to go to a different school. I left all my friends and favorite teachers behind because I didn’t want to be stuck with her another year. I wouldn’t wish this on anyone. Home Schooling is the best way to make sure you don’t get someone like that.
FACTS FACTS FACTS!!!!! I’m just 16 and homeschooled, but I watch my public schooled friends at my church, and I see their attitudes, both towards each other, and their basic moral beliefs. I originally felt inferior in knowledge and public speaking abilities but that’s just not true. They all want so badly to not offend any one, and to be in the in group and be considered cool, when it doesn’t really matter. People aren’t kind any more, and I miss the southern hospitality I used to get with my homeschooled friends. They were kind, and were gentle in word, though they would tease you as a sign of love, but not out of cruelty like I see other places. I know I’m just spilling, but I want people to see from my perspective what it’s like. I have good grades, and I live in the country. My parents raise me with basic and proper moral standards: respect and treat women with dignity, love your country and your freedoms, love your fellow man, no matter his skin tone(all lives matter), and live a life that is beneficial to those around you, and to the kingdom of God. Kids education should be up to the parents, not the government
I did most of elementary school before I convinced (begged) my mom to pull me and my brother out. Best decision we have ever made. I love just being at home not having to worry about all the drama and headaches that come with school. I have run into a few of my schoolmates over the years, and they have all said that I made an amazing choice, because my school has been going further and further down the drain. I pray that it will get better, though.
I’m from Italy, but I do remember (from personal experience), that I learned more by studying on my own than in school, not to mention the social issues that happened in school (like teachers not doing anything against bullying or teachers humiliating students with understanding issues) My only question (since I’ve never heard about homeschool until recently), what about diplomas and degrees?
Little late to this article, but I was homeschooled from kindergarten through highschool. There are some problems with homeschooling and it really comes down to how your parents choose to do the teaching. However, I got my questions answered when I raised my hand and my parents gave me one on one help when I struggled. My mom was probably one of the best English teachers one could have. I can’t tell you how many times my papers came back dripping like a raw steak. She challenged me to do better and accepted nothing but my best effort. It was eye-opening when I went to college and found that the bar for a passing grade was so low I was tripping over it. It was simply do the assignment, meet the word count, read the book, write a coherent sentence, show up to class. Grading on a curve was the norm. Students were always begging for extra credit, but doing the bare minimum. Then they would come in at the final and try to get the professor to change their grade. If you want to see the end result of the public school system, take a couple of basic classes at a junior college and watch your dreams of a better future wither and die.
Obviously we should have the freedom to select which way we school our children, including homeschool. That being said, I still firmly believe that a form of group schooling (whether public or private school) is beneficial to the social development of kids. I think school choice is a more admirable pursuit then just pushing homeschooling, there are plenty of private schools that also address a lot of these concerns.
As someone who’s not making this a public versus private issue I promise, and someone who is never homeschooled, the homeschoolers I know are absolutelyThe best socially adapted people I know. It’s been so much time with students older and younger than them and with more adults in really great environments. So many of them are so talented and intelligent. Almost all of them I know are musicians and really good people who didn’t make bad decisions and hype really intelligent.
I think we need to both, see homeschooling as a more normal option, and make public education better. Homeschooling isn’t always an option for people. In my case my dad has a condition called dystonia so he had been bed ridden for most of my life, so that means my Mom has had to go and work every day, leaving nobody at home to possibly homeschool if we even where to consider that option. So public education should still be there, but as an alternative.
I was a latchkey kid who was homeschooled from the 5th grade onwards. I used to spend my days in public and private schools getting teased and beat up all the time, meanwhile…in homeschooling, i knocked out all of middle school and high school by the time i was 15. Started college, enlisted, served 8 years, went back to school and have a decent career and a couple degrees to show for it. If i had stayed in public school, who knows where i would be…certainly not where i am today.
1:35 really hit close to home. I had a teacher who was a serial molester. Three things allowed this individual to target young boys, over the span of a 45 year career in public education. 1) Stereotypes that boys crave sex, no matter how young. 2) School working very hard to cover up any possible scandal that might reduce paychecks. 3) Stereotypes that women cannot be sexual predators, especially if the victim is male. Last spring, she died after a very long, slow, (hopefully painful) decline from advanced uterine cancer. and to anyone who might think ‘well this probably high school’ it was middle school. And she didnt pick the kids who would brag about it (the ones mostly likely to enjoy it) she picked the most bullied, and the least responsive to her more subtle ‘coaching’ during class times. Basically targeting the late bloomers, gay kids, and the kids least likely to speak up. I spoke up. And was promptly tossed in a mental ward after the school reported i made bomb threats and threatened to accuse the staff of sexual assault over a failed grade. Side Note: I had been victimized by another woman while in foster care, who tried to perform a bathroom circumcision on me. At the time of the second event, i had severe scarring that made normal bodily functions extremely painful. Urination left me in tears. My abusive teacher knew about the prior abuse, and used it as a weapon against me, threatening to tell my classmates about it. (and threatening to call CPS and have me put in foster care again)
Another thing is the close relationship you’ll get to have with your kid. I have a very healthy and loving relationship with my parent’s compared to a lot of the public schoolers I know. Also, I was allowed to grow and learn at my own pace. Took a long time to get my math up to the “right level” but was reading classics like The Count of Monte Crisco and 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea by age 12. I remember being 7 and being told that I was at a sixth grade level for reading. I was disappointed because I wanted to be at a seventh grade level, so my grade level would match my age. 😂
A lot of this is just related to how people learn in general. I used to be a private tutor for about three years, two years through a company and one year on my own before I took a job in leadership in a laboratory. People learn better on all accounts when there is a one-on-one relationship with the teacher. There’s no distractions, there’s no pressure to be better or worse, there is no nervousness for appearing stupid. A teacher can also better assess what the student needs to succeed and address those issues personally. I was a teacher in math and science from grades 8 to 14. One of my happiest moments was when I was able to teach a sport’s kid who thought he would never understand math trigonometry so well he was teaching his friends at public school. Public school was NEVER designed to teach. It was designed to detain and indoctrinate. It teaches how to respect authority and nothing more.
The best reason to ban Home (and private) Schooling, is so that the rich elite has an intrest in making sure, that public schools are good. Otherwise if the decisionmakers about public schooling have no reason to adequatly fund them, (and in fact even reason to hinder it,) the public schools will suffer.
As someone who went through both public school and homeschool, homeschool was better in almost every way. It varies state by state, but in mine all you had to do was 4 hours of schoolwork any time every weekday. You could start the school day as early as 4am or as late as 7pm or any other time, you just needed to put in the hours. The only downside is if you don’t have a regular and reliable way of seeing your friends, it gets lonely.
Honestly, I’m slightly glad I was not home schooled as my parents were a nightmare and were dysfunctional as all hell, being near them for prolonged periods of time would have made my life even worse. That’s not to say that everyone would have the same experience as me and would not benefit from Home schooling. Although, between the options of Home schooling, Private schools, and public schools I would say the following: Public schools should be used for those who don’t have the money (or time) to educate your kids. Private Schools should be used when you have money but either don’t have the time or want to have a prestigious name on your resume. And home schooling should be for those who can afford to educate their children properly and go without belting out corporal punishment when you get a question wrong.
I don’t know I went to a small, rural, public school that was well funded and I think I was better served than some home school kids I met. Academically, if it’s done correctly, I don’t doubt their would be advantages in homeschooling as you can teach to one or a few students instead of 15, but the few home schooled kids I’ve met are pretty socially awkward. Ideally homeschooling needs to include lots of interaction with other people and parents who are dedicated because otherwise it’s a risky decision.
I had to send my child to school from home school because she didn’t have social skills and was very lonely. Granted she would get a better education at home, but I had to weigh her mental state to a slightly better education. Thankfully she now goes to one of the top public schools in Georgia. There’s a mural of Jesus Christ in the elementary stairway still at a public school. ( I’m sure it won’t be there soon! It takes 1 parent to complain). We did try private Christian school, but she was actually getting bullied there. There wasn’t a strong principal to correct it. He felt love, caring and prayer would correct the situation and he was wrong! The girl didn’t have a father figure at home. She was very manipulative. Sadly she’s already had 1 abortion at 13. The bully will be lost soon if someone doesn’t take control of her and act like an adult!
I’ve learned more in the past four years in college than I have my entire grade school years. Especially about the concept of failure and pushing through said failures. I feel I’m gaining knowledge and experience that is worthwhile and is actually relevant to my life rather than the tidal wave of useless factoids and petty drama that was highschool. All and all, as long as you can afford to financially and timewise, I would say homeschooling or private schooling is the best way to go for your kids. Especially with what they are trying to teach our kids now.
The problem with homeschooling is that socialization goes from being a coincidence to a chore. I feel bad about it now that I’m an adult, but my friends and I literally avoided the homeschooled kids for the longest time. They weren’t just weird, they were serial killer-esque. We ended up befriending one out of exhaustion after he more or less stalked us for months. Prior to us, his only friends were arranged by his parents. Once he realized what normal people acted like, he begged to go to public school. He went from creepy stalker to popular athlete. Of course, home schooling shouldn’t be banned. I just think that the greatest benefit of public school is passively learning how to interact with people, and that’s easy to overlook.
There are good ways to homeschool and there are bad ways to do it. The times when I’ve seen it most successful is often with big families that have frequent contact with other families and are generally gregarious. I was homeschooled up through 5th grade by my dad. The main reason we didn’t continue past that was because he worked full time and couldn’t devote more time to my education as it grew more complex. However, I was the only child, lived in a crummy neighborhood, and both my parents were pretty introverted… so I didn’t really get out much. While I was very smart, it did leave me socially and emotionally stunted.
I was homeschooled all the way up to high school, where I then did online classes. I was homeschooled because my parents don’t trust public schools, and seeing how my cousins turned out, I understand why. Two of my cousins had to go to mental institutions, one of those two went to jail, and the others, save for a few, are liars, thieves, and more. I’m not gonna say I’m perfect, but at the least, I don’t do any of those things. Furthermore, during standardized tests, I did better than my cousins. While they scored within the 50-70th percentile, I scored between the 80th-95th depending on the subject. Additionally, my cousins were exposed to more mental harm than I was, that is to say, things like pornography, bullying, fights, and the like. It’s not like I didn’t have any kind of bullies, I have siblings, after all, but the bullying in schools is far worse, not to mention, when it comes to fights, you never know who is and isn’t armed. Overall, fuck the public school system, homeschool your kids.
There are bit this information that needs be updated… I was listening to news report showing that the child abuse at home was heavily on the rise since the mandatory homeschooling, as well as kids having social issues. Though, this is of course a very special case and not a normal home school environment.
I found this website because of the tim Pool appearance. I quickly subscribed and if you have other websites that are as good as this I’d like to subscribe to them as well. I appreciate truth and that’s all im finding on these articles. I’ll be sharing them wide and far. Thanks for the hard work it’s worth a lot on the current climate we’re in to have sources of realistic information vs garbage we see on the news. Be good and much 🙏🏻. Happy thanksgiving!
As they are now trying to deem parents domestic terrorist for interfering in what public schools are trying to teach their children. I agree that parents should definitely homeschool if possible. Work with other parents to rotate school responsibilities. Many companies are allowing 10 hrs/4 day weeks so having five parents adjust their schedule to lose no hours and cover one ‘school day’ each might be easier that one parent giving up their career.
I was homeschooled 6/12 years of schooling I have, and let me just say I liked homeschooling more. I would complete all my lessons for the day in an hour(online classes/schools so not traditional HS) and have the rest of the day to do things I actually liked, like reading history and science books or going for walks. I also didn’t start homeschooling for the normal reasons as my parents didn’t really have a problem with my schools(except the last one) it was more I didn’t get along with my class mates or the school was to slow for me as I always excelled when doing work by myself more so than when I was in a group.
Home-schooled kid here. DAMN STRAIGHT! Want statistics. My parents either dropped out of or barely graduated college late, and were lower class when raising us. My siblings and I were all home schooled. Since our parents couldn’t do lab experiments or teach foreign language, we all finished up by going to high school. All but one of us was valedictorian when we graduated, and all of us either have, or are getting, graduate degrees. I am the only one out of work right now, but that is a combination of disability and current (**cough**) economic/hiring policies. We all own our own phones, cars, and places to live, have savings accounts, are at least $10K into 401ks, and have clean criminal records. Now, I understand correlation doesn’t mean causation, but then you can’t say home-schooling doesn’t work either.
Every time somebody makes the “social skills” argument in advantage of public schools I feel as if they never went to a public school. Don’t they realize how many kids are alienated because they are stuck in bad environment with shitty classmates? They act as if homeschooling meant locking your kid in house 24/7 without ever letting them participate in any group classes or social events
Not an American, went to public school; my dad was amazing at keeping me and my siblings cultured, and I don’t think I personally could do a better job at raising a kid. Even if I wanted to homeschool my kids, I would be propagating my own failures from when I was their age (i couldn’t even teach myself proper grammar, so I fear for the kid I’d have to teach that to – like, i understand the relationships between words and whatnot, but remembering the terms for everything? It sucks, but you do need to know that in school)
Problem is, most adults are not qualified to teach higher level STEM. Homeschooling is a decent option up until about 6th/7th grade, but after that the depth students need for most subjects is beyond most parents, sometimes due to the parents own understanding of particular subjects, but usually it’s that the parents just don’t have the time. Saw it co stantly with COVID during last semester. Also, not all teachers are far left leaning socialists. THERE are those teachers, and I cannot stand them. Anyways, saying abolish public schools is about as wise as saying abolish home schooling. Either situation can work for different students, but our national idealogues on both sides don’t want to have that conversation.
Did you guys read your own sources; “It is important to consider; however, that these are subjective questionnaires completed by children’s parents and it is difficult to determine the validity of parents’ views of their own child’s social skills”. I have 7 people who where home schooled all through our high school, straight into college not one of them is socially adapt. No matter what their parents might think of their social skills.
A free government will rarely ban anything. If a government does ban something you should be asking why, is it really for your safety or their power. To tell the difference just listen to them, are they offering alternatives, improvements, allow for debate, or allow counter evidence to their points. If any of these come back no, then it’s not about protecting you its about their power.
I absolutely can believe that homeschooled students have better social skills. I was homeschooled, I’ve been socially awkward pretty much since birth, and I’ve always been a loner, but the jobs I’ve done best at by far are ones where social skills are critical, like sales and being a Range Safety Officer. Meanwhile, I’ve worked with my public schooled peers and they are hopeless at dealing with anyone. I’ve got my fair share of difficulty with people, but at least I can tell that self deprecating humor and weird Gen Z speak only makes you unlikable to a hyper masculine Russian, which is a surprisingly high percentage of my customer base
I didn’t have better social skills. I got scarred for life, and never figured out how to form successful romantic relationships. Clearly not everyone isn’t going to experience harsh bullying upon finally entering public school (after 3 years of rather ineffective homeschooling) for being so culturally different, or experience a crippling lack of social IQ that didn’t start to get ironed out until college, and helped contribute to becoming a virgin well into my 30’s. You’re milage may very. In retrospect, my mom admited that she realized too late that the Calvert home school program was a poor choice for my learning style.
think the benafit of homeschooling is the teacher has to teach an individual, instead of a large group, allowing for the child to get help with parts they have trouble with, and ultimately not have the problem anymore; instead of just being told”its wrong” or”it’s correct”. i think how public schools can adapt to…the reality of actually helping a kid learn. is smaller classrooms, better scedualings(like NOT STARTING AT 8:00-8:30 EVERY MORNING)and trying to make it fun/interactive to learn. i still remember school being bad at times. it should also be reorganized from it’s core outwards. 3 years of middleschool had me: be the brightest kid in school, raising their gpa, was plopped into a “special” class to learn what I needed to, but the teacher knew nothing about me, or the fact I was reading at a highschool level when she was giving me kndergarden level worksheets. and after my smarts were diminished, the next year, one problem(they let me get away with quite allot of shit when I was the smartypants)and they threw me away.saying”they couldn’t handle me” so I’m saying the whole thing should be reorganized to be less a business of students being “smart” and more a system to actually TEACH the kids the basics, and then focus on what they are interested in.
My girlfriend of 2 years and her 5 siblings were all homeschooled, and of the 4 that are college age, 3 of them are enrolled in college, and they all perform extremely well. However, they are practically asocial, bordering on antisocial. Beyond that, some kids in my Boy Scout troop were homeschooled, and yeah, trend was the same. Though I guess, getting a job or starting a career will eventually reverse or fix that, to some extent. I wonder how many home schoolers feel like late bloomers, from a social standpoint.
True story: I had terrible grades in school to the point that I was placed in a class for the learning disabled one year. They took me out of the class the next year when they discovered that the only reason my grades weren’t amazing was because I was constantly being bullied (being the only white kid in school will get you targeted real quick). The other thing that teacher noted was that I never got a bad grade on a quiz or a test. When my mother found out, she took me out of public school and set me up with a home schooling curriculum, complete with classwork, homework, etc. With no extra drama to drag me down and being graded on meaningless social issues, I went from being a failing student to always getting all A’s. There are ways to socialize your children, folks. There are also good programs for homeschooling that don’t require you to be any smarter than anyone else to guide your kid through them. I went through a program called “Abeka” where I literally watched real classes go on and learned from the best teachers at a private school. All my mother had to do was grade tests and Quizzes with the master book. At the time this was kinda revolutionary. I’m betting that these days there are similar secular programs.
The public school system is going down hill. For the reason of the high property taxes to fund facilities, over pay teacher salaries and benefits. If you come to this comment saying $25-$31 an hour is not enough (Sit down and think about how much a Journeyman electrician makes, or even a cop) and do not forget the COLAS in the areas. Also look what your school superintendents make in salaries and benefits for the amount of work they do…
homeschooling is bittersweet for me on one hand when i was older i was able to be pulled out of a toxic environment that laughed at the attempt on my life but on the other it was done earlier in life and they just didn’t teach me science almost at all when i went into 3rd grade i was way behind scientifically and in 6th even argued with a teacher over how old our earth was along with mocking one of my former friends by using a straw man of evolutoin
Still should be given their per pupil voucher, and all curriculum that public schools have and/or they learn about a trade, or find other prep for their dream job. Or else, a severe lack of accountability will make public schools look good. Doing so without any regulations will only end miserably. As for social skills, that’s why we need social prescriptions in this country to gain integrity from big pharma and big therapy. Otherwise for the love of god, Join a homeschool co-op with non-religious options or the government should step in to make sure special needs aren’t isolated to their homes and to create social connections. Making the homeschooled take IQ tests is clearly not enough.
Homeschooling should never be forbid and always be an option. The only problems I see is that the child would lack the possibility to explore other view points may it be religion or politics, this could be countered by attending some sort of sports or other means to meet people of the same age. And another far harder issue to solve is that in unfortunately many parents are not qualified any more, a mix if online teaching and home could solve that. Final point many children sadly have both their parents having to go to work and stay more than 10h away from home. The chil of left at school where anything can happen from getting robbed, learning to be a bully etc. For this final problem I have no ideas
I was molested by a american teacher that moved from country to country every time he got court. I was the last he done it too as he took his life(oh what a shame). So yes i agree home schooling is better. Cos if you knew how many times i was assulted by other students and one other teacher. Its no surprised i ended up in icu.. and put spent 6months in hospital. Oh did i mention this teacher was sleeping with a (male) head of the pta plus molestering his son as well. Long story short, dont openly trust ANY ONE with you kids life/future. Im in my 40s and it still messes with my head from time to time.
had a discussion with someone, who works to make Estonia´s education system better. when i asked her if she has seen a rise in homeschooling thanks to the virus, she laughed and told me that they made regulations on homeschooling so hard to achive that noone is stupid enough to consider this as a option
What about the possibility by bias introduced by homeschooling for example those that devalue scientific theories like evolution? And it’s going to be hard to teach critical thinking skills in such a isolated environment. With public schools there is a chance for seeing how other people behave and think and can even challenge our beliefs. But in a homeschool environment are we expected to believe that parents are going to be unbiased?
the thing this and all other arguments for homeschooling do not take into account is social isolation. think about it your stuck at home, without anyone other then your family, learning things from an extremely bias teacher, your parents. and lets say you go to a program or a group to prevent this, well those are just private schools with extra steps. on paper those are tutors, or activity groups but the parent is paying the same price for a private school if not more just to say that they “did all they could”. i come from homeschooling and am speaking from experience. please for the love of god do not home school your kids, use that money to send them to a private school, and if you say you can’t afford to do that then you can’t afford to homeschool
When I get a child, I will home school them if I can. There are a lot of things that I disagree on with the schools, like how they do sex education, by that I mean the LGBT stuff and all. There are also bullies that the schools do nothing about (the bullying awareness campaigns are a joke and a lie), and most of the time, the schools have horrible people inside them. One of the things I really want to do is also to connect to my children, to help them personally and much more. I want to do everything I can as a parent to help them and engage with them. For social interactions, I guess I would just take them out to the public area, but of course informing them on how to behave and all, also I don’t want them going with the wrong types of kids, like those that do drugs.
So to sum it up in layman terms Homeschooling is a symptom of a failing educational system that grows in proportion to how alarmingly bad public schools are and shrinks as public schools improve. This is a natural indicator that we should allow and pay attention to to figure out how to make schools better.
As a homeschooler myself I really agree with this article my brother and I a very severe dyslexia and ADD/ADHD as well as my brother is autistic when we were at the private school kids through rocks at my brother because he was interested in rocks I got no help in my reading or math which I greatly struggled in and it was deemed that I was just too stupid to do anything
Homeschooling, private, and public education are only as good as the lower of either the teachers’ capability or the restrictions imposed by the administration. That is going to lead to a bit of sample bias towards homeschooling, because most people who take their kids out to homeschool have the time, money, resources, and willingness to focus on one kid.
My problem with homeschooling is that as a solution for education it doesn’t scale well. Sure, some parents are wonderful, and have lots of free time to educate their children, but many more have full-time jobs, and lack the financial comfort to do this. If you want to make education better on a societal level, that change has to happen in the schools. Abandoning ship doesn’t help.
I would love to home school my kids! But I work a full time job and manage rental properties outside of work. I try to tech as much as I can. I just wish that I had more time with my little ones. My wife works full time too. She gets more time with the kids. But still not enough to be able to teach them full time.
um… I grew up traveling around the country quite a bit, spent years in public schools in washington state, florida, kentucky, and more, after graduating from highschool and joining the military my the trend of never being in one place for more than a couple years obviously continued, I’ve never once heard anyone ever suggest banning homeschooling, ever. The whole public schools demanding that parents be banned from sitting in on their kids work-from-home education during covid lockdowns weirds me the fuck out though
It depends on the kid. I did better when I had to go to a place outside my home to be educated. The same goes for work. Also, not every parent is fit to properly educate their own child. Social outings are a must, and the ability to teach isn’t as common as it should be. Then there’s the problem of religion. That should be 100% on the parent, not the school, to endoctrinate that parent’s child. When the whole point of schooling is to prepare children to enter the working world as an adult, things like political ideology and religion have no place in school. The closest any child should come to either is in his or her history class. The rest can be gotten at home. All this is to say that neither system is perfect, and thankfully, there are resources available to help those that both systems have failed.
On the other side, one reason that I think would influence the public school idea is that some parents can’t handle the overactive energy that a young kid usually has. Some of them actually get worn out trying to keep up. Still, I agree that it’s the parent’s decision. Of course, the South Park episode on this topic is hilariously exaggerated. A couple of days in public school and the girl becomes a whore.
2 noted form this btw. Let’s not forget the fact that kids can emancipate themselves proving to she they are competent to take care of themselves under law in the united states. Of course they may have to be guided by a guardian until they are of legal age. Also you can have your kids homeschool until they are trained to take the exams so what is the point of bitching about their conventional way to kids education is beyond me.
While I completely agree with pretty much every point made in this article, I would still argue that the social setting of a traditional public school provides certain, non-academic qualities that simply cannot be replicated in a home-school environment. This is, of course, not to say that home-schooled children turn out better or worse than public-schooled children, just that it really is quite like comparing apples and oranges.
Yeah I agree, children are much more likey to be abused by teachers and children in public school. I heard a story from someone today anout children throwing chairs at each other in the middle of a lesson, I dont think that happens when you are homeschooled. You can also focus on the subjects you actually want to do when you are homeschooled (not much point in atheists learning way Jesus is king and there is no point in conservatives reciting woke ideas) and you aren’t limited by the curriculum. In multiple subjects I was left with nothing to do or learn because children in public schools still struggle to do multiplication by the end of elementary (or equivalent). Even social skills are likely better if you are homeschooled at least in the internet era. You don’t get bullied and you don’t have to suffer through a class of people you hate. Instead, in those breaks you can talk to people who can relate to in some way. If your homeschooling parent is smart enough to have a degree of some form they can probably teach you better than the state. The only times where its better to go into a school to learn is when you are being abused by your parent (much less likely to be abused whilst being homeschooled than while going to a school though) or when your primary education from homeschooling has paid off or you can get into a school where you have to pass a test to get in (not sure the names in the USA because I’m from the UK (don’t worry our system isn’t much better)).
I must’ve gotten unlucky or some shit cause I had the worst experience in homeschooling, I know my parents were only trying to do what they thought was best for me but it fucked me over and now i’m a junior in high school trying to do online classes but struggling and on top of that I have zero friends and have pretty much no social skills. life sucks rn
My boyfriend was severely abused and his homeschooling education was very stunted because of his mother. Im aware that the statistic of abuse is low, but he was literally brainwashed into thinking everything he was going through was normal. There are more cases like him. Public schooling sucks but homeschooling needs improvement too.
True I feel a child being socialized by their family siblings and neighbors is far more likely to be well adjusted then throwing them in a discipline and consequence free environment where they will inevitably learn more from their idiot classmates then their teachers who are far left Bernie bros anyway.
Public schools ain’t perfect and believe me I know. Homeschooling however is not perfect either. I have personally met homeschooled kids who are very bigoted and close minded. They treated me and my friends horribly and thought we were the brainwashed people. Now I am not saying this is the case for every homeschooled kid. One of my good friends was home schooled and sees me and my other public school friends as an equals. However just as left wing indoctrination is prevalent at public schools, right wing indoctrination is prevalent at home schooled homes. Kids should not be brainwashed and instead figure stuff out for themselves.