Child Protective Services (CPS) are often called upon when a child is in danger due to physical abuse, sexual abuse, or behavioral signs. These services can be overwhelming and frightening for parents, but they are essential in ensuring the safety and well-being of children at risk for medical neglect.
To report abuse, call the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline at 1-800-4-A-CHILD (1-800-422-4453) or find your state organization’s contact information. CPS is required to share allegations and evidence against parents if the agency decides to remove a child from the home or file a petition in court. If a child is home alone, CPS can talk to them, but it varies by circumstance.
There are five criteria CPS needs to register a report: you do not need to be certain that child abuse or neglect has occurred before calling the Hotline; you do need to know how to handle a family member who keeps calling CPS on you for ridiculous reasons; and you must be aware of the First Amendment’s prohibition on discrimination against persons based on religion.
If you think a child is being harmed or neglected, contact CFS at 1-866-345-9241. If this is an emergency, contact your local police emergency number. It is important to know everyone’s rights and responsibilities when receiving Child Intervention services. If a parent is causing harm to their children, it would be right to notify someone in authority to deal with the problem. However, there are times when calling CPS is the right thing to do, and all parents should be able to recognize the signs of child abuse.
In summary, child protective services are essential in addressing physical and sexual abuse, as well as other forms of abuse. It is crucial for parents to be aware of their rights and responsibilities when receiving these services.
📹 Redditors used CPS to target Christian parents
Two weeks after having their eighth baby, Britney and J.D. Lott, who run a popular Instagram documenting their cross-country …
What can and cannot CPS do in New York?
Child Protective Services (CPS) in New York have strict regulations regarding the entry of individuals into their homes and the compulsion of drug tests. CPS cannot enter a home without permission or a court order, and can only request a parent to do so with a court order. Navigating the complexities of child abuse or neglect accusations can be overwhelming, but having a skilled lawyer can provide invaluable assistance. New York Family Law Group, a specialized firm, can help handle child abuse cases and ensure the best legal representation possible.
The complex laws surrounding child abuse and neglect in New York can be draining, especially when working with inexperienced lawyers. Contact them today to schedule a consultation and let them advocate for your best interests.
What is considered child neglect in NYC?
Child neglect is the failure of a parent or caretaker to provide necessary resources to a child, threatening their health, safety, and well-being. The Family Court Act of New York defines child neglect or abuse as the act or failure to act that results in death, serious physical or emotional harm, sexual abuse, or exploitation of a child under 18. Child physical abuse includes inflicting or allowing someone to inflict serious physical injury, such as shaking, beating, biting, kicking, punching, and burning.
Child sexual abuse includes incest, rape, obscene sexual performance, fondling a child’s genitals, intercourse, sodomy, and other contact such as exposing a child to sexual activity or commercial sexual exploitation. Child neglect is defined as the failure of a parent or caretaker to provide necessary resources to the child, threatening their health, safety, and well-being.
What are the negative effects of forced religion?
Forced participation in a child’s life can often result in a number of adverse outcomes, including rebellion, resentment, or unquestioning obedience. These outcomes are antithetical to the development of genuine faith and understanding.
What behaviors do children of multiple religion-based maltreatment display?
A child’s misfortune within the home can be attributed to a number of factors, including financial difficulties, marital discord, infidelity, illness, or bereavement. Alternatively, it may be the result of behavioural issues such as disobedience, rebelliousness, or the experience of nightmares.
How long can a 9 year old stay home alone in NY?
In accordance with New York State legislation, there is no specified age at which a parent or legal guardian may leave their 12-year-old child unattended for a few hours after school until they return from work. The parent or guardian is held legally responsible for any potential harm to the child.
What are the limitations of CPS?
The Central Prosecutor’s Office (CPS) has a disadvantage in that it heavily relies on the police when deciding whether to prosecute cases. The CPS is free to examine potential cases without considering the police’s views, but they might still be influenced by them. The majority of cases brought to the CPS are from the police, and they have limited time and resources to thoroughly investigate each case’s police files. This has led to criticisms that the CPS is not fully independent from the police and is more inclined to prosecute cases brought to them by the police.
Additionally, the CPS’s overreliance on case notes makes them more likely to be swayed by the police’s point of view, as they may know potential prosecution targets from their day-to-day work and be biased against them before the case reaches the CPS. This can lead to more prosecutions where it is not always necessary.
What to do when your parents force religion on you?
Coping with overly religious parents can be challenging, but it’s essential to surround yourself with supportive and accepting friends and family members who accept your beliefs. Create a mantra to cope with upset family circumstances and consider factors like age, abuse, living situation, and resource utilization. In a healthy parent-child relationship, unconditional love should be shown, regardless of your belief system. Parents should accept you for who you are and support your growth, allowing you to have differing beliefs and values.
They should not reject you based on your beliefs, and they should understand that you will develop into a unique adult and not expect you to be a carbon copy of their beliefs. This approach can help create a more positive and supportive environment for you and your child.
What rights do parents have when dealing with CPS Montana?
Montana’s public policy significantly impacts children and families, but often lacks consideration for their impact and families’ participation. The Montana Child Protection Alliance aims to engage all stakeholders, including families, community members, and service providers, in effective advocacy. They work closely with legislators to introduce bills that aim to keep children safely with their families and avoid the traumatic experience of entering foster care. Bills supporting family rights that passed during the 2021 legislative session include:
- A 5-day hearing at the time of removal;
- A copy of the affidavit;
- Attending hearings;
- Contact information for case worker, supervisor, and Public Defenders Office;
- Requesting kinship placement.
What is an example of religious abuse from parents?
Religious abuse is a form of psychological manipulation and harm caused by religious leaders or members of a religious community, occurring in any religion or faith. Examples of religious abuse include using religious teachings to justify abuse, enforcing harmful religious rules, shaming or ostracizing non-conformists, using religious authority to manipulate others, and denying access to basic needs in the name of religion. This abuse can have serious and long-lasting effects on individuals and communities, including trauma, emotional distress, loss of faith, and physical harm.
It is crucial for individuals and religious communities to be aware of the signs of religious abuse and take steps to prevent it from happening. The motivations behind such abuse can be either well-intentioned or malicious. It is essential for individuals and religious communities to take steps to prevent religious abuse and protect the well-being of their communities.
Are parents allowed to force religion?
Forcing religion may seem like a helpful tool for parents, as they believe their child will eventually find their faith and believe in their actions. However, it is not possible to force someone to believe in something, as a child will always believe what they want to believe. Some kids may be less interested in religion and practicing it if they are forced into it. Instead, they may discover religion on their own through research and exploring different values, practices, and cultures.
The author’s personal experience shows that their parents never forced them into religion, but attending a Catholic school with a religion class taught the same passages from the Bible and the values they should have.
What can and cannot CPS do in Washington state?
Courts must review child removal cases, as CPS cannot remove a child without court approval. Police can only remove children if there is imminent danger and can hold them for up to 72 hours. If a child is unlawfully removed, CPS must notify parents and detail the circumstances leading to the removal, and parents have the right to choose their child’s placement. CPS must consider parents’ recommendations.
📹 Jo Frost Alerts Child Protective Services When She Believes She Hears A Child Getting Spanked
The TV personality spoke to ET on Friday after cameras captured a father allegedly disciplining his child with a belt.
The worst part is the kid saying he doesn’t know why hes in trouble. How is it effective to beat a kid when you wont even communicate what they did wrong. If this is how they acted knowing they could get caught i can only imagine what they do to that poor boy when no camera is around to see. They dont deserve children
My mom hit me with ever what ever she could grab, belts, pans… throw stuff, plates books. She was violent and a narcissist. She hid behind this spiritual person, a holistic healer and a vegan facade…. but behind closed door she was a monster. People who didn’t know her, adored her. People who knew her wouldn’t pick up her calls.
I live in South Florida, and all the time I hear shit like, “Yeah, I’m proud that I beat my kids. Teaches them a lesson.” …To hate you? To be violent when they’re angry? To do it to their own kids when they grow up? To not trust you and end up being severely emotionally crippled because they can’t talk to their parents?
It concerns me how many POC like myself defend plain child abuse because we grew up with it. We need to do better with our children. Edit- Y’all can continue defending child abuse and lazy parenting all you want I’m no longer replying to comments 🤡 I’ve already given examples and other people have provided info on the long term effects of beating your children but ignorant people will stay ignorant. “You can lead a horse to the water but you can’t make it drink”. I don’t need to explain my comment any further.
Like a lot of POC as a kid I was disciplined with a belt, hand, shoe, and sometimes a spatula or wooden spoon. My parents grew up with it and so did their parents and so on, my parents thought that if they hit me I wouldn’t do it again or I would learn my lesson. They always said to me, “One day you’ll thank us for disciplining you the right way” when In reality it only made me hate them. You see parents believe that threats and hitting will teach your child to behave when it only makes your child scared. Growing up with physical punishments made me think it was just discipline, I now know that this is downright abuse. And when I become a parent I want to be different because I would never want my children to experience physical pain just because they did something wrong. And I urge parents or future parents don’t hit your kids, talk to them tell them you are the one in charge, if you put maturity and some aggression in your talking you children will understand who is the one making the rules, if you hit them they will only learn that hitting others is ok and if you want to be the parent to send that message to your kids I hope you know the consequences to your actions.
Study after study after study has shown that assaulting your child as “punishment” leads to violent behavior as they get older, depression, anxiety and resentment towards you as their parent. Is your child old enough to understand reason? If no, they will not understand why you are striking them. If yes, you should be using reason and not using your kids as an outlet for your anger
Since I’m African being spanked/beat as a child was pretty normal, but since I was the last child I never got hit much. Lots of people turned out fine after being beat, but I never understood the purpose. You have a child who is smaller, less powerful, and more naive than you and to show them that certain behaviors are wrong you inflict pain on someone who is considered a part of you. Yeah, when kids get to a certain age, they may “know better”…but when elementary school teachers get in disagreements with kids do they hit the children? If your spouse does something unacceptable do you hit them? would you hit your own mother? your friends? I’m sorry, but a kid being your child doesn’t justify that violence to me. YOU are angry at what your child did so YOU take your anger out on that child? instead of finding other more solid ways to teach the kids it was wrong? I get it can be a quick fix but if you’ve had to spank your child more than once over the same thing then clearlllllly spanking/beating doesn’t work and only results in shutting your kid up for a few hours or days.
If you guys want some more perspective on why hitting it counter productive… I was a HUGE brat growing up. I could’ve been on super nanny. I would throw fits ALL the time. My mom hit me (I am now no-contact with her) all the time because of it. She one day had enough, and contacted a woman at her church named Donna (lol I just realized they have the same name). I must’ve been 4 at this point. Whenever I really acted up, I got sent there for the weekend. Donna NEVER hit. Whenever I threw a fit, she would sit me down on her lap, and just hold me there until I calmed down. She then asked if I was ready to apologize. If I said no, she would keep me there until I apologized. Eventually I cracked, and apologized. She only had to do that twice, and just like that I was completely changed. I would never throw a fit at their house, and I obeyed. The second I got sent back home and threw a fit, my mom would just hit me, and would never try to learn the techniques Donna used. And I would just get worse and worse and worse over the years, until my anger issues snapped and I blocked her out of my life. If you want your kids to respect you, and not run off at 18, don’t fucking hit.
Hitting a child, with or without a belt, is unacceptable and, frankly, lazy parenting. As an adult, you have to maintain control and composure at all times (as much as humanly possible). How are you preparing the child to handle conflict in the future? What does hitting teach them? The fact this was toward a disabled child makes it that much more disgusting.
I remember a time when, before I had children, someone asked me something about the topic and I said that I thought that beating and whipping children was unnecessary and that there are better ways to make children behave. Now that I’m a parent, I’d say something different. Instead of merely describing it as unnecessary, I’d describe it as unjustified, abusive, and totally unacceptable and should be illegal. Yeah, I said it. You thought I was going to say it’s okay to beat on somebody who is smaller than you? Not a chance. Too many people take out their frustration and anger on the child, pointing to something wrong the child did as though it were justification for the adult’s actions. I cannot imagine betraying a child’s trust in that way. I’m supposed to protect them, not hurt them. There are plenty of other ways of nonviolently disciplining a child. I use them in my household and have respect and order in my home.
People need to stop saying “it happened to me and I turned out fine.” Whether they know it or not, they’re obviously suppressing the fear and pain they didn’t deserve to endure growing up. And state officials who grew up in an abusive environment like that are only making it worse for children today by doing nothing to stop it. It’s a lot easier to use force than effective communication. If a parent has the balls to hit a child in order to get through to them, but not the balls to own up to their mistakes years later, then they never should have become parents to begin with.
My dad did this to me all the time. He got so angry and verbal with me one time. That I literally ran to my room and locked my door. My dad had busted his way in and I literally was backed into a corner screaming “get away from me!” “you’re scaring me!” It took 3 mims to get my step mom to finally step in and pull him away from me. To this day. I still have that impending blood running cold feeling when people stand near me or the feeling will creep up on me one day, and my heart starts racing and I can’t calm down for a good awhile. While I understand punishing your kids for bad behavior. That kinda treatment ain’t the way to do it. It borderline abusive in ever word. He’d one whipped me 12 times with a belt because “I had misbehaved during a school trip” but nah that teacher witch got check mark happy is what it was (I was in special Ed even though I shouldn’t have been I was acting out as a child die to the abuse and fear I suffered as a child growing up. But nobody really cared tbh)
I see people saying “i got spanked and look at me I’m fine!” What People who defend spanking need to realize is that not every kid is going to react the same way to being hit. While i don’t believe in spanking at all some kids may be fine after being spanked, but every kid is different what’s nothing to one could cause distress and long term mental pain for another.
I believe most people who spank their children either have anger problems or were also ” spanked ” and think it’s normal and also think fear is the same thing as respect . The cycle continues and continues until someone breaks it . When I encounter someone who does believe in spanking I asked them to just imagine how they would feel if someone twice or three times bigger than them would be threatening them with physical violence. The people who are like ” I was spanked, and I turned out fine ” . Probably have some issues and don’t even realize where it came from . When I see deeply problematic children or even adults, I always wonder how their childhood is/was .. so much of what we do how we behave or have other relationships is obviously directly from how we were raised .
Honestly, children can feel guilt so when you strictly and sternly speak to them very slowly, looking them in the eye, they will understand. It’s adults that can’t be disciplined with words, but children can. Hitting or beating a child is not necessary at all and adults do it just a power move, which is wrong in every way.
I have to say its great to know theres loads of people who disagree with smacking their kids. I was physically, mentally and emotionally abused by my adopted parents. I was adopted because my birth parents neglected me. I was abused since I was born. My adopted mum was the one who would constantly smack me in the face really hard where my mouth ended up bleeding and was swollen the next day. She smacked me over my head so many times leading to headaches and dizziness. Even my adopted dad smacked me over the head but he regretted it after and apologized. but my adopted mum always punched me and my brother around and she never felt guilty or apologized. she said it served us right and that we deserved a good punch. smh she even locked my brother in the shed when he needed the toilet. When I first moved in with them I pood in the bath and my adopted mum smacked me straight away and shouted at me as I ruined her bath and she had to clean it up again. All this abuse started when I was 3 years old and my brother 2 years old. I am 28 years old now and married and have kids myself. I never abuse my kids ever. Oh and I dont let my adopted parents go anywhere near my kids unsupervised my husband and I are always there perusal them, even though my daughters dont want anything to do with my adopted parents. I told my husband everything what happened to me but adopted parents are lying saying that they never hit me etc….. they even got my brother to deny it aswell which pisses me off. I know the truth and so does my brother he even admitted the truth to me on skype in front of my husband that he was hit aswell as I was.
My whole generation grew up like this, and most of us lived to tell about it. I personally don’t hit my children, but I do believe the lack of discipline is a huge problem with children these days. Parents shouldn’t be afraid to discipline their kids. A man yelled at me today for yelling at my children when they were misbehaving. I didn’t even hit them and he screamed in my face what a terrible mother I am.
Says “turn around” Has a belt in his hand “Oh he’s just scared” Yeah? NO, first your child shouldn’t be scared of you and second, he clearly beats the child. He has that belt in hand ready to use. Even if he didn’t use it that time there was clearly something up before jo came and it included that belt. The kid sounded terrified.
As I’ve always said and always will say, hitting a child is not helping them know what they did was wrong. It is just instilling fear into the child, the fear of getting hit by you if they do anything they think YOU might think is wrong. If you hit your kids, expect them to never confide in you, because they will always be scared of you, and you just traumatized your own child.
I’ve never been hit by my parents and I think I turned out fine. I guess I may have been a rare type of kid, though, because I only needed to be talked to in order to understand what was right and wrong. My mom told me once “When you go to work when you’re older, your manager or the person in charge won’t hit you. Even though I’m in charge, I don’t think that I should hit you either, because i’m supposed to be teaching you what’s right and wrong.” Now, my biological dad was a different story. He actually wanted to physically spank me and lay his hands on me when I did something that wasn’t to his standards, but my mom told him no. I’m glad that she did, because I would have been even more hateful of him than I am now if he did hit me.
If you look into behavioral psychology you would see that “punishment” is the least effective way to correct a behavior. A good behavior should be rewarded through positive reinforcement and discouraged through negative reinforcement. A punishment is different from negative reinforcement and can lead to an individual shutting down and never completing the behavior that is wanted. The difference is a kinda hard to understand (and way to complicated to explain in a comment), but when used properly negative reinforcement works 100% better than punishment especially in mentally ill children. I do not have any kids, but I have been fostering aggressive and behavior issued animals for over 3 years and have seen the difference myself and recommend that anyone with children or pets (or even relationships) learn how to properly negatively reinforce a behavior instead of punish it.
I have a special needs child (autism) and their brains are literally different from a “normal” child’s. They aren’t defying you on purpose, they are struggling with something….same can be said for a “normal” child as well, but chances are this kid has autism and was triggered or overstimulated….hitting him solves NOTHING. Plus the child might not even UNDERSTAND WHY he is being hit by his own parent. This breaks my heart. I wish I could adopt him. Good on Jo for being a wonderful human being ❤️
I don’t believe that corporal punishment is effective. In actuality, studies have shown that children who are disciplined in this manner are more likely to misbehave further. Instead, we should punish with timeouts, etc. and reward good behaviour. It works a lot better and it means that the child doesn’t have to be in fear of their parents all the time.
Parents need to step into their kid’s shoes every once in a while. How would you feel if a person three times the size of you hit you with a thick leather rope with a huge metal buckle at the end of it? You would be terrified! And you would be even more terrified if said person was chasing you and screaming at you! Parents need to get it together and grow up. Learn how to discipline your kid and stop taking the easy way out that is likely traumatizing your child. The kids didn’t choose you to be their parents but you chose for them to be your kid!
When I was younger my dad would slap me or spank me with a leather belt, but when I got older my dad always asked me why I never open up to him or share things with him or love him like how I love my mom those were the reasons why I was scared of him and I didn’t want to go through it again. Later on with my boyfriend we somehow talked about kids then to disciplining kids and I said I wouldn’t spank or slap my kids ever because if i hated it they would too if I was terrified of my dad so will they to me.
Corporal punishment for children is the reason many people grow up battling with their self worth and ego. Lots of them grow up feeling they deserve this pain to get a drop of love out of the person who does it to them and or go on to mimic said actions. To beat your child for a mistake/disagreement should be the last option when trying to raise a functioning citizen in society. As a society we need to normalize gentle parenting and stop making it seem like it’s just spoiling your child, words, lessons and experiences are more suitable ways to teach your kid valuable.
Okay, beatings include, belts, switches, fists, this is what I got growing up. PUNISHMENT for children open handed spanking on the behind, IF time out and taking toys/games/play time away doesn’t work. I have a special needs son and he’s never been beaten or spanked. But my techniques work for him. He doesn’t get yelled at for being human, for making mistakes, like we ALL do. But if he hits someone else, bites, scratches, ect. He will be punished and have to sit, and that’s literally the equivalent of a spanking to him (I’m assuming) because he does not like staying still, but must do so for four minutes, we go by age for timeouts in my home. After his punishment, I explain to him WHY he got put in time out, and that is because he did not listen to mommy or daddy about being safe and kind, or was mean to his sister/ his friends/ my husband and I and hit/bit/pushed/threw toys, ect. He learns by being treated like a human being and met eye to eye. Some parents should have classes to even see if they qualify to be a special needs child’s parents. I know my punishment sounds rough but I’d rather him sit for four minutes than go through what this poor baby went through. I hope he isn’t traumatized and afraid anymore. How sad is it for a special needs child who cannot make mistakes and be human without being beaten with a belt. It literally crushes my soul.
as a child, I remember getting spanked, whipped, and also my brothers and sisters getting whipped. it was very traumatic. it made me angry, and I would often hit my brothers when we had arguments. hitting seemed to be normal behaviour, I had no idea it was wrong. I did behave out of fear, but I became good at lying to escape punishment. “did you do that? NOOOOOOOO” when I reallly had done it, but lying sometimes worked to get me out of being punished. my daughter decided not to spank her boys, she was strict and didnt let them get away with stuff, but she never hit them, and both boys grew up into fine young men. I like that they have never been hit, will probably never hit their kids, or their wives…
Everyone likes to bring up “Withhold not correction from the child: for if thou beatest him with the rod, he shall not die. Thou shalt beat him with the rod, and shalt deliver his soul from hell” but a rod and a belt are different. and it’s not a literal rod. the rod (Hebrew: מַטֶּה maṭṭeh) was a natural symbol of authority, as the rod tool used by the shepherd to correct and guide his flock was different. It’s talking about guiding your child with verbal conversation. not physically beating them. they’re not sheep.
As a mother and special needs Londoner, I can’t get my head around the American mentality that violence is discipline. I see muricans boasting that it did them no harm, but I can tell that it did from a mile away,it would take me a few minutes to write a summary of my observations in that regard,but it would be detailed.
If your child is too young to be reasoned with, then they’re too young to be hit. If your child is old enough to be reasoned with, then REASON WITH THEM! TALK TO THEM! As a parent, if the only way you can get your point across is beating a child (because that’s what you’re doing, not ‘spanking’, but deliberately attempting to inflict pain) then you are a truly shit parent who shouldn’t have had kids. Hundreds of studies have proven that children who are regularly hit grow up to have a host of issues. So all of these “Oh, well my parents hit me and I’m fine” claims are bullshit. We all know that it’s unacceptable to hit other people, but if you think it’s OK to do so with a child (who can’t even fight back), then there’s clearly something wrong with you.
i think there’s a difference between spanking and using a belt. i was spanked as a child with a hand. only once at a time and very rarely. i think using a belt is considered abuse. that can leave welts and using an object to beat your kid i just… you can’t always control how hard it’s going to hit them. i think giving them a pat on the ass is effective but don’t beat your child
hitting has been proven to have worse effects on your child than doing any good. in fact id does not work at all!!! anyone who belives in ‘whopping their kids ass’ is absolutely not deserving enough to have the privilege to be a parent!!! my toddlers are EXTREMELY well behaved!! everytime i go in public i get compliments on how well behaved they are….i do NOT lay my hands on them. but i also dont allow them to do whatever they want either. my secret is i am a PARENT. i dont sit on my ass all day on my phone while my boys watch tv or play article games all day. that is NOT parenting. i am INVOLVED in my childrens lives keeping their minds busy with play, arts and crafts, reading books, swimming, zoo, children’s meusum, vacations. that is parenting! when my children are older they will have all they need to succeed on their own……those who choose not to parent are setting your kids up for failure
I hate this! What’s the point of beating any child let alone a special needs one! Hitting your children only a sign of you losing control and want to sit it by violence. I don’t approve it and I don’t think it is necessary . People with short temper need to raise themselves and look into their abilities to be parents before pushing their temper and lack of abilities on the kids. Teaching your child to fear you isn’t teaching him anything! He will only avoid you and do it behind your back which is most parents know it happens! They know it’s useless but it releases their stress. I truly don’t see my mother in the eyes of love. I see a 20s old frustrated girl who has nothing to do with parenting so she found hitting or burning me a useful way to keep me from doing what she resented. Now that didn’t ever taught me anything is wrong or harmful to play with because I only understood few things are not approved yet growing up, I can see she was a very reserved person that dancing to music was too loud for her and I needed to be burn for it! Go figure what kind of parents find this helpful!
I live in a latinx household and that was how I was disciplined growing up. My parents would hit me with a belt, chanclas, wires and/or whatever they had near them. I really don’t blame my parents too much because that’s how they were raised(but even worse) and they didn’t know any better. I can say that corporal discipline does NOT work having gone through it myself. And I now have trauma because of it. And a whole list things wrong with me 🤠
My mom used alot of physical and emotional punishment when I was kid. My dad used to just take things away from us and then calmly explain why we wrong and how to go about things in better ways. As we kids grew up. We only ever felt like our dad was the only one who cared and who we could turn to and who we respected. Never my mom. My dad also had his ways of showing he loved us. My mom never did. I’m 30 years old and ive never once in my life remember my mom ever saying she loved me. I cant ever remember her giving me a hug. Never… The way you treat kids and punish them really does have affects on them. So make the right choices. All kids will be “bad”. You have to teach them and help them learn.
I’m reading these comments and I had no idea people went through this stuff. My mom never really spanked us, my brothers more so than me but they always laughed when they got spanked. Usually she would sit us down and tells us why what we did was wrong and such. She always listened to us and made sure we completely understand what we did was wrong. She was super nice and understanding.
I don’t want to hurt my children like that. Ever. I still flinch when someone raises their voice, and when my parents argue with my siblings I have to leave the room. One time I was out with my friends, and a drunk guy pushed another down and started fighting, and I couldn’t tell them why I was crying and shaking. I don’t want to put my children through that, and if I feel like I can’t control myself I simply won’t have them.
My mom consumed alcohol while pregnant with all 5 of my siblings. She was so unfit to be a Mother, courts gave my grandmother custody of 5 of her kids, including me, the eldest. She used to hit my special needs siblings all the time. She also let our other cousins physically abuse us everyday. Whenever someone was being abused there was nothing we could do but run away and hide from them for what felt like hours. I used to climb in my closet and hide on top of a dresser behind cloths hanging up because it was hard to see me there. I used to hide under the bed and I would move empty shoe boxes to obscure myself when they looked for us. I remember when they found my sister hiding inside a Wardrobe, and she just screamed for her life. That was the most terrifying moment in my life. People wonder how I’m so strong when it comes to strangers and their criticism and it’s because my family was my worst of enemies and theybweee supposed to be family. If family hurts you and you survive, nobody on this earth can hurt you.
Feel free to disagree. I was spanked as a child, even with a belt once I was older. Do I think I was abused? Absolutely not. I’m very close with my parents, I was never scared of them, and I was on disciplined when I actually needed it. Kids need discipline, and sometimes kids don’t listen with just time out or talking. Do I think you should spank your kids if you’re beyond pissed off? No. That’s when it could become abuse. That being said. Yes he is a special needs child, I work with them daily, and not all are as far on the spectrum as others. Some completely understand what they do, and therefore they need discipline of some sort. I would lean more for timeouts with those kids. But I have seen the occasional kid who is just flat out mean, and understands his actions. Kids like that, I think spankings would be necessary. Not abuse, but a hand across their butt. That’s the problem with today’s society. We don’t discipline our kids, and then parents wonder why their kids end up being disrespectful, and trouble. Something I’ve seen is parents try to find a diagnosis when it is a lack of discipline on their part. No child is going to be a functioning human if they don’t understand the word no, and don’t understand their actions come with consequences. It’s called life! Stop wrapping them in bubble wrap and trying to be a friend. Be a parent first.
I just think spanking and physical punishment of any kind is creepy and unnecessary. Jo has proved time and time again that you do not need to resort to that for your children to learn a lesson and change their behaviour. IMO, spanking is lazy. Take the extra time to give your child non violent punishment.
My older brother had hyper autism which caused him to have severe tantrums. My dad would beat him up severely due to that, this continued till he was 16. Now my brothers 18 and about to turn 19, i still remember the screams from the closet where the beating would happen. The screams just echoes in my mind, and i just wish that i was older enough at that time to have understood the extent of abuse and call cps. Once im done with completing my studies and get my job, im going to take my brother with me and go no contact with everyone who were involved and remaint silent on the abuse. I wish to make my brothers life better, thats all i want.
Spanking rarely if ever fixes any behavior in able children. Kids dont associate pain with a need for better behavior. They associate pain with fear. And all its does is make them fear you. Not their behavior. If youre gonna spank a kid it cannot be a casual every day thing. Which its is to 90% of parents who spank. This man cant spank with a belt, his disabled kid for crying and acting out. Jfc.
Where was Jo when I was a kid? D: I’ve never agreed with spanking, ESPECIALLY when the abuse includes a tool like a belt, stick, wooden spoon, etc. I’m a mother now and I’ve refused to use this form of punishment on my child. The results? Praise from all of his teachers about how respectful and kind he is. He also has special needs, although considerably mild, and I can’t imagine using this form of punishment on him when he’s already well behaved. We discuss mistakes and how to handle them. We discuss behavioral problems too. You’d be amazed at the positive results you’ll see in your kids by just talking to them with the same respect you want from them.
No one should be belting their child; especially if they don’t even understand they did something wrong in their parent’s eyes. My father was belted by his dad when he was a child. My dad belted me growing up too. The difference was that my dad never did it hard and it never hurt. He just wanted me to know when I did something wrong. My mom put soap in my mouth a few times and held me down to the ground and hit me hard when I was in about 5th grade. My dad was the one who never called me names growing up; he always talked highly of me to and was so kind to me.
There is nothing wrong with spanking,beating yes, spanking no. People forget that at our core what makes us, us we are animals. We learn from pain like it or not that in it self is the truth. we touch something hot and burn our hand we learn. Children are learning at around 2 and up “what is this world really about?”, they are testing their boundries; testing the waters. This is how they learn and a parents window of teaching. You know your child better then anyone else. You know when all other methods have failed or are not working; you know when spanking is called for. Many people forget to be parents because they what to be friends first. You are a parent first and a friend last. Period. I hate to see children these days. People do not know how to parent anymore. If you can’t keep them in line/behave in public, I can only imagine what they are like at home.
Just because it worked for you doesn’t mean it works for everyone. I was always a quiet kid and because my parents hit me whenever I did something wrong I became even more quiet and afraid of everything and everyone. Even as an adult I still get frightened by a lot of things I shouldn’t be. Calling people a pussy because being hit made you tougher is dumb when it doesn’t work for everyone.
We got spankings with numerous things. The worst part was the fear of having to walk up to our parents for the spankings. Children should not fear their parents/guardians. They need to be respectable and that comes from adults calmly talking to kids/teens if a rule was broken then a natural discipline to follow if need be. Hitting, spanking, whipping, threats teach children the same. Break the cycle. Be parents, not friends.
I don’t believe corporal punishment should be the primary form of punishment but I do believe it necessary in some cases. Not all children respond to discipline in the same way. I mean, jail isnt a deterrent for 100% of adults. The same is true for kids. Time outs aren’t a deterrent for 100% of kids. They sure as heck weren’t for me. I just treated them as nap time. Got up and did the same thing again immediately after getting up. I don’t think a special needs child needs corporal punishment though.
I was really talkative when I was young, especially since I grew up in a warm community in the Philippines. When I moved to America, I once got in trouble for talking too much and the teacher called my parents. When my dad heard that, he taped my mouth until I got a nosebleed. It was very traumatic for me. But, I got it off easy because punishments much worse than what I went through occur a lot in the Philippines. I once heard that someone was told to kneel on uncooked rice while holding books on each hand.
when i was little, i got spanked if i did 3 “bad” things. any more and i just get more spankings with worse degree. i really dont know what to say about this because obviously im fine now (i have depression but it’s genetic/chemical) but when it would happen i always sobbed from the pain and thought my parents hate me. there is a difference between beating and spanking, but almost every parent seems to have a different idea of spanking. mine would use this thick rubber block thing. it’s weird, my parents were fucking religious about spanking too, they said it was defying against god to not spank your child ????wtf.
A Negative reaction to a Negative action will only =Negative results. Kids respond to positivity way more than they do to negativity. They do it also in a learning manner & not because of fear. We want them to feel safe,protected,& trust us..not fear us or be physically & mentally hurt by us. A flower grows because of love,sunlight,water,enrichment..not being neglected,forgotten,smashed or damaged. YOUR CHILD IS A REFLECTION OF YOU & YOUR PARENTING (with the exception of those that are suffering from mental illness or any type of disability..those situations aren’t the children or the parents fault) kindness goes a long way..with results vs hate and anger that get you nowhere..but hurt. God Bless those that try their best to be a good loving parent♡ It’s a tough journey sometimes but it’s the most beautiful & magical one..cherish it & your precious children
Hitting kids in not okay. Hitting a kid with SPECIAL NEEDS? Absolutely horrendous! Kids with special needs don’t need to be threatened and hit. Parents of kids with special needs need to be calm and patient because those kids sometimes don’t understand certain things. Hitting them for no reason, or to get them to “behave”, just makes them scared of you and sometimes makes them think that hitting others is okay when it isn’t. I have ADHD/ADD and as a kid, I had trouble with paying attention, doing schoolwork, and I also had anger issues, especially in 5th grade. My mom disciplined me in many ways, the corner, writing a sentence over and over, threats of spanking with a wooden spoon, “punishment food” (which meant I ate only one type of food and ONLY that food), yelling, and even a spanking or two. My uncle (not blood related, but a friend of my mom’s) even got in on this. These punishments made me hate my mom and fear my uncle, as he was a strong man. He would even threaten to hit me if I was crying due to a breakdown; the phrase “Quit crying or I’ll give you something to cry about.” seared fear into my heart and soul. My relationship with my mom and uncle got slightly better as I got older, but I will always remember the pain, hate, and fear the punishments tattooed into me. Hitting your children NEVER gets you anywhere. In fact, it can only make it worse. Your children will fear you and even hate you. Sometimes they will never even want to talk to you again because of it.
Same with my family, I think their emotional immaturity led to their behavior. I think you shouldn’t have children if you can’t think of serious consequences for actions with a message that isn’t, “You have no power in our relationship, your opinions don’t matter, and hurting others is how you get what you want.”
People who think miss behaved children in public is an outcome of not hitting your kids, when it’s actually the opposite. Kids who are beat misbehave in public cause their parents can’t yell and hit them, while kids who get time out when they get home will shape up immediately. Why beat your kids it’s destructive in so many ways
My mother whopped me and my brothers and we learned appropriate behavior, respect, and grew into good adults. I corrected my children with a spanking when they needed it, and they are awesome young people who know how to treat others. When done with love and not meanness a child learns correct behaviour.
Spanking is okay unless it is abusive and only up to a certain age. Little kids don’t understand let alone care about revoked privileges and consfiscated items. So, by spanking them they are learning, oh shit i better not do that again. Because does a child understand “Aww well Timmy, that wasnt nice dont throw things, see now i have to take away your toy and you dont get dessert” No they dont.
funny. one time when I was a kid I acted like a fucking brat and my mom spanked me. It didn’t hurt that much, but my pride was hurt. So my (literally) butt-hurt ass told her it’d be funny if I called the cops and claimed abuse. She laughed at me and said I should go ahead and do that, and make sure to enjoy my stay in the orphanage when child services comes to pick me up. Obviously I didn’t make the call, and best believe I hardly needed to get spanked after that. Most kids that get ocassional spankings (not abuse) would rather stay at home and behave than get taken away by child services.
My parents spanked me and used corporal punishment as it’s called. they always exhibited love they listened to us, they talked to us, they made sure that we knew that you were the most important thing in their lives they were not going to allow us to waste our lives. I don’t think it’s anyone’s right to tell someone else how to discipline their children once those children are not being abused there’s a vast difference between corporal punishment and abuse once those children are not being abused and they’re being disciplined and shown direction and love that is no one’s business she had no right. No one has any right to impose their beliefs on someone else and especially not concerning the rearing of their children. My parents where and are God fearing people that believe in the word of the Bible and lived by it and made sure that we lived by it and in the Bible corporal punishment is the way indicated and that’s the way we grew and we grew well
I’m not even able to watch the article, but this form of discipline is the most barbaric and outdated form. You’re just an underdeveloped caveman who acts on his anger if you do this, and nothing can convince me otherwise. I think people who do this are lazy and lack the confidence or motivation to LEARN and better themselves for their children.
eh, I got spanked, and one time with a belt, didn’t fuck me up but I have great coping skills, so for me it was ok, and looking back on it I deserved it. There are some individuals out there that do not respond well to spankings and it can cause severe damage, so it’s one of those gray areas. There are also children that will not obey even after every soft parenting tactic has been deployed, so as a last resort spanking is used. I think it works for some kids, but overall it shouldn’t be the go too.
You know how some police officers frisk you? By making you spread your legs apart, putting your hands against the wall. Well that’s the position I was told to go into then the corporal punishment began. I always tried to count how many lashes I would get but I would always lose track after 23,it’s like I left my body . I still count when I see someone being beaten but I never make it past the number 23.
Imagine not being able to understand someone bigger than you standing there with an object they want to use on you, and the questions in your mind are “why don’t you love me, why are you hurting me, why am I not good enough for you to stop…WHY?” That poor baby, I hope he’s not with them anymore and he’s getting the love he deserves.
hey Jo Frost!!!!! I was smacked with a paddle. and guess what? jam still alive, I have Manner’s (unlike kids these days who aren’t smacked) I can sleep at night, I can go out in society. and guess what!!!!! I can even color and stay in the line Jo Frost 😉 your beliefs and opinion don’t matter when it comes to kids that aren’t yours 😉
You have to compare it to if you attacked someone in the streets. If you got your belt out and started to attack/hit some stranger on the streets with it you would get arrested, so why on earth could anyone think it’s alright to do that to your own children in your house, especially where they can’t ask for help. It is violence and It is abuse.
Corporal punishment is wrong in every way my parents never needed to beat me to teach me how to behave they taught me how to respect them and other people and make me realise when my behaviour was wrong. Beating ur child is just lazy parenting and abuse and if you think corporal punishment on children is okay in any circumstance then I beg you please don’t ever have kids or get help.
This was so upsetting. I am a victim of a step father who disciplined me with a belt. It caused a lot of trauma; I have a fear of certain types of individuals because of it. Jo did the right thing; no child should fear the adults in their life, no child should be beat into submitting to a grown ass adult. Use your words and teach your children how to be a better person – beating them is only teaching them that that’s what they’ll need to do to get their way when they’re older.
you have to remember that these are CHILDREN and they are developing as time goes. So they need an explanation for almost everything because they are LEARNING. Communication with children, not abusing your children. If you hit your kids or let someone hit your kids, your a bad parent. Yes, I said that. There is no reason to hit your child. They are LEARNING AND DEVELOPING.
I was spanked and we got the belt sometimes but I am grateful that I grew up having respect for my elders. The children and teens I encounter in this day and age (some of them) do not have any respect for their elders and they talk to people any old way with no consequences. I don’t think you should abuse your kids or hit them in anger but they do need discipline.If they don’t have discipline they will grow up with entitlement issues or worse.
The science is out and corporeal punishment causes a lot of psychological damage, and is a risk factor for later delinquent and aggressive behavior, along with a host of other difficulties. Corporeal punishment is lazy, cruel, and usually done in anger. What the hell are you teaching kids when you can’t even show them how to solve problems without aggression and violence?
We got spanked when we really misbehaved but still felt love in our home. All 6 of us grew up to be accomplished successful people. We behaved in a certain manner because we were afraid of the consequences NOT our Mom. She was a single mother trying to prevent jail/pregnancy/death from her children. If done correctly spanking isn’t wrong. Everything isnt black or white.
It should be a federal crime to beat a child. I don’t get why states allow parents to physically, verbally, and mentally abuse their children. If a parent is going to beat their child with a BELT, they should have their children taken from them and they should be sent to prison. Children don’t deserve to live with parents who will abuse them. Those parents deserve to be locked away and not allowed near another child ever again.
This is made worse when you realize this happened over the kid not following unreasonable requests to stand in a very specific spot on the floor next to the “dad”. The kid was ready to listen to what he had to say, even moved to where he thought he was supposed to a few times. He was confused, then when the dad flat out touched the floor where to stand it was pretty much on. All while the mother lazily sleeps on the couch, only getting up to go, “you better do it now or I can’t help you”. Your kid doesn’t want to move right next to you because you beat him. This guy has problems. He wants control so he exerts it over children. Making irrational demands of where specifically to stand to talk to a child just so he can justify exerting his power over a child wirh special needs. WHO HAS SEIZURES. It’s disgusting and abuse. You’re not fine even though your parents beat you, because you acting this way proves otherwise.
I was beaten with a belt by my Mom at least 1x a week for 17 years. When she would call my name with a belt in her hand I would piss myself in fear. I can still feel my body tremoring and I’m 56. I never even spanked my 3 sons, not once! All 3 of my sons are responsible well rounded adults. But I had 4 siblings one lived homeless for 17 years, one lived most of his adult life in prison before he hung himself, one sister abused her children and my other sister is a severe alcoholic. I was the only one who got help when I became an adult. Anyone who defends child abuse in any form, uses it in any way is a scumbag and beyond weak. Anyone who can lay a hand on their children do not love them.
Stop saying special needs, it’s dehumanising and a very harmful euphemism. We are DISABLED. Stop avoiding calling us disabled, it just shows your ignorance and ableism. There is nothing wrong with being disabled, so why you keep avoiding calling us that? It’s the exact same as avoiding calling a black person a black person, educate yourself and stop using euphemisms.
I was spanked as a kid but only twice that I can remember it wasn’t that often and it was only a couple of swats. spanking isn’t abuse and is affective but it depends on the kid. I’m not saying that its always the best method or option though sometimes there are better alternatives to punishing your kids especially if they are special needs. but people shouldn’t be telling others how to discipline their kids. let them discipline their kids however they think they should and what they think is best just because someone uses a method of discipline different than yours it doesn’t give people the right to tell them how to parent their kids. the parents know what is best for them just like you know what’s best for your kids
I was spanked but it always a pat on the butt never hurt just very humiliating. Some parents do intentional hurt the child to get them behave which is horrible, there are other ways to discipline a child that doesn’t involved abusing physically l. When I have kids I won’t spank them because it can be damaging to a child emotionally and physically.
My step dad did this to me and still both do when I’m 27 years old and I am born with a condition called microcephaly similar to aurtisum and they look and he takes my phone and I’ve been depressed all my life because what I’ve gone through. He open bathroom doors when I’m using bathroom or take shower . He once left me up on the wall when I’m trying to defend my self when he was shaking me and he always finds way to have a agreement . They don’t listion . He treats me different because my real dad abandoned me when I was born because I’m dissabled and he did not want to be a dad and because I’m step dad so he treats me different than my half little brother and sister that is his kids with my mother . Im afraid of him . I wish super nanny comes to help .
I know yall disagree with spanking, but it’s not abusive. It’s okay to spank a child if their acting bad. I really hope people don’t actually get arrested for this. Bro if this is actually illegal in Georgia, then that is a really dumb rule. Yes, people may not agree with it, but it should not be illegal. Spanking is DISCIPLINE. Its nirmal to spank your child. It helps yhem nit be spoiled in the future. And people who spank tgeir kids, they are doing it because they love them.
First I would like to say, this article is about a mentally disabled child, so of course it will be traumatic for him and the father is not spanking in the correct way. You have to spank with love not anger. Also, a lot of you are mixing up abuse and spankings, there’s a huge difference. Maybe your parents didn’t spank you correctly so now you’re colored by the experience? Idk. The same ones acting like spankings don’t help children are the same people now living in a world where children are acting more spoiled, entitled, teen pregnancy has skyrocketed, teens that do drugs, drink alcohol, even some kids as young as 5 breaking into homes and playing with guns. Kids back when I was still a kid were more respectful and responsible, not perfect but things were better back then than they are now. I don’t believe complete fear needs to be put into children but I firmly believe in correcting children and spanking in the RIGHT way. I also don’t believe in using spankings for absolutely everything.
I honestly dont care what anyone says, SPAKING IS NOT CHILD ABUSE. There is a difference between spanking as a form of “no” and straight up abusing your child. People act like one or two hits is going to mentally derrange a child when thats not the case. I bet people who grew up with anger issues from the spanking had other factors that accounted for such negativity. Such as argumentative parents, unfair treatment with siblings, neglect, and so on, but i can bet actual money that a healthy family that spanks their children will not end up going left. Not every child is the same so you need to find what form of discipline works best. Some respond well to time out and unwell with spanking, and some respond not well with time out but listens with spankings. Saying its Child Abuse to spank a child waters down the term to children who are actually being abused, BEATEN, starved, emotionally neglected and so on. A spanking is no where in the same waters as child abuse. And if you think CPS will respond to a child being spanked think again!
I grew up with ADHD and Dyslexia and also have depression and anxiety it’s junk but I have kinda accepted my learn disability but it was hard in honest till today I take ADHD medication cause I took it since I was young. And I grew up with strict parents who do not tolerate bad behavior. So I feel like there should be discipline to a point. And find other why to help your child with adhd or other learning disabilities if can medication isn’t always good.